Reflections of a Star
by ABatsEyeView

Comment:
reflection? You lost me on this one.. - setzler

First Submission
by jlr

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 5
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 8
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 7
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 6

Score: 7 - setzler

Leaf Pool
by Swashbuckler

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 6
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 8
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 4
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 5

Score: 6 - setzler

Head & Shoulders
by Damitriel

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes, but it's very weak...
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 10
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 8
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 10

Score: 9 - setzler

This is a really nice shot. The surface of your subject is reflective, but the reflection itself is not what makes this subject intersting to me :)

A happy reflector
by marcvg

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 8
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 6
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 8
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 8

Score: 8 - setzler

Yellow Boat
by Jean

Comment:
This photo was grossly underrated... keep up the good work... it's on my fav list :)

Yellow Boat
by Jean

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 10
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 10
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 8
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 10

Score: 10 - setzler

The lighting is a little too hot towards the front of the boat. I would love this photo even more if that was toned down just a little :)

The 3 Amigos
by Richi

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 3
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 7
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 4
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 4
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 4

Score: 4 - setzler

Old Technology Meets New
by ganders

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 6
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 5
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 8
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 7

Score: 7 - setzler

Past, Present & Future.
by Kavey

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 8
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 10
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 10
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 8

Score: 9 - setzler