Through Each Others Eyes
by Count

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: no... camera is visible...
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 3
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 5
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 4
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 6
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 3

Score: 4 - 3 (challenge not met) = 1 - setzler

One Dog Over All
by pauld

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 3
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 7
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 3
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 4
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 3

Score: 4 - setzler

Reflecting on Bathtime Memories
by Sonifo

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 7
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 8
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 7
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 7

Score: 8 - setzler

Looking down upon us all
by falvey

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes - I can tell that the image was photographed off a revlective surface because of the funky color...

Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 3
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 5
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 5
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 8
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 3

Score: 5 - setzler

Desktop Managerie
by hedonist

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 1
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 4
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 4
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 5
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 3

Score: 3 - setzler

the sight of sound
by cq107

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 10
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 10
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 10
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 10

Score: 10 - setzler

Excellent shot :)

The Tennessee
by indigo997

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 9
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 10
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 8
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 10
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 10

Score: 9 - setzler

I'm curious to see what this image would look like with the bridge light white balanced out... try this: open it up in photoshop and go to the hue/saturation menu and desaturate the green channel to see if it will remove the green tinting from the light here... :)

The Beverage
by tattyrob

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 6
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 6
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 6
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 8
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 6

Score: 6 - setzler

Note: This image would probably be stronger in some other color tone than sepia. Sepia is traditionally used to impose an old or antique look. The 'modern' sunglasses here don't seem to fit into an 'antique' image :)

Frog Pond
by amandolin

Comment:
Meets the Challenge: Yes, but it's weak...
Artistic Merit (Would I print/frame/hang it?): 7
Creativity (Did a lot of thought go into this photo?): 3
Technical (Focus/DOF/Lighting/Etc): 7
Composition (Subject well-positioned and framed): 4
WOW Factor (Is the photo interesting?): 7

Score: 6 - setzler

I would love to have seen the reflections play a more prominent role in your photo. Reflections do exist here but they are not creating the 'wow' in this image...

Reflecting On Our Reflections
by amonteforte

Comment:
I'm impressed!!! This is phenomenal.. twins :) = 10 - setzler