2 girls 1 puddle
by posthumous

Comment:
Have to admit I didn't get it. Partially because I was looking for human girls. I didn't even see the right dog's nose. Once I saw your description of "drinking from", it clicked.

Introspection
by MinsoPhoto

Comment:
Awesome photo. Definite and immediate emotional connection, with enough "What the...?" to make you stop and study it.

My Friend Dee
by tanguera

Comment:
Smile. What a great capture!

Paper?? It's all in his game!
by Kroburg

Comment:
Great capture of the playfulness of the dog. This is a fun image that readily connects with any dog lover, as well as potentially with childhood memories of playing with a loved pet.

Bianca
by docpjv

Comment:
Oh very young
What will you leave us this time
You're only dancing on this earth for a short while
And though your dreams may toss and turn you now
They will vanish away like your daddy's best jeans
Denim Blue fading up to the sky
And though you want him to last forever
You know he never will
(You know he never will)
And the patches make the goodbye harder still.

Our families and heritage are not ours to choose. Yet some of us have been blessed beyond expression. May we recognize the gift we have been given, and pass it down to the following generations. And may they do the same.

Rocks; I chose rocks for crossing my Rubicon. You bet!
by docpjv

Comment:
The precarious balance. Taking it one step at a time. Sharing the path with others, but at the same time competing for limited resources. A selfish moment can ruin the crossing for everyone. But, by sharing, everyone gets where they need to be.

Bubble of Note
by docpjv

Comment:
What a great capture. Such a transient moment. Here for a moment, then gone. Yet it captures the attention and imagination of those who are privileged to witness it. All caught in a single, colorful, captivating image. Beautiful!

Cold Feet
by nam

Comment:
I like. Some nice things about this - the sunrise/sunset colors, the geese framed in the pool of light, the reflections on the ice - all work together to make this a mighty fine shot.

glass cup
by emmykay18

Comment:
This image has a combination of issues without a counterbalance of positive qualities. On the positive side, the point of view is different, the subject is colorful and different (with the rim around the bottom, it almost looks more like a pot than a cup, and it is being used to hold writing implements rather than a beverage or a plant - so one is left wondering exactly what it is - and its context doesn't really give away the answer).
To me, the biggest issue is the background - especially on the right side of the picture (which is even worse because the pencil points to it). What is in the background is critical to an image - either supporting your main subject or detracting from it.
Second issue is the lighting - not sure I can figure out what is going on there, but it looks like the light is coming from the top left, but the left side of the glass is dark while the inside right side of the glass is almost too well lit. To me, this makes the left side of the image dark, pushing the viewer's attention away from it (and, following the pencil, to the distracting background on the right edge).
The third issue is that the image is not in focus. Images can be deliberately blurred, and that is a potential for this image. But, it doesn't seem like it. Depth of field is a critical choice, but generally some part of the image should be obviously in focus.
I think you have shown great creativity by "seeing" this picture in an ordinary every-day setting, and capturing it. Technique can be taught - the ability to "see" a picture, not so much...

Fragile As Glass
by sashiii17

Comment:
Be very aware of the background - if where you shoot can't be controlled (and sometimes it can't), try darkening it or lightening it or massively blurring it in post processing. Don't be bummed by your score - pushing the edge (especially of a challenge description) does not usually encourage high scoring. BTW - your crop on this is very nice.