Remembering Last Summer
by crik

Comment:
Having the foreground shells in as sharp focus as the glass jar mouth would've improved this shot for me.

The Understudy
by smurfguy

Comment:
Too dark - may just be my monitor. Great idea, though.

Scotch Broom
by cogerox

Comment:
This feels overprocessed to me. Otherwise, I love the colors and the reflection.

In the Dark
by jim300

Comment:
You must really believe in making taking a picture a real challenge. This is a tough shot, and - for me - your entered result has some issues. The major one is lack of focus (in two senses - the sharpness of the image, as well as a major focal point to draw the eye). The large dark area in the bottom half draws my attention - because of both its size and location, but there is literally nothing there to see. I do like the contrast of the red and black - on the emotive side, this has strong contrasting elements, where even the positive element (red) is not entirely so. This almost feels like "danger!" or "warning!".

Closing Doors, Opening Heart
by Mitzenfauker

Comment:
The heart formed by the shadow is almost too subtle - almost missed it. This shot is just a bit too much of nothing but a bit too much. I want to like it - nice concept, and well done. Perhaps a crop at the bottom of the heart shadow would get rid of a lot of the extra without taking away the soul of the shot.

Art, Everyone's a Critic
by Leo

Comment:
That's not Art. That's Steve.

She will Find You
by TomsPhotos

Comment:
Too dark for me. I think this could have been lightened a fair amount without losing the mood.

Aunt Eunice
by PennyStreet

Comment:
For me, what gives this shot that "extra punch" is the beautiful lighting on the gold foil on the neck of the bottle that ties into the gold on the frame. Very nicely done.

If life sends you a Lemon, make Lemonade!
by macobee

Comment:
I like this a lot. Excellent use of the pitcher & bowl tying into the lemon & limes' colors. Using a white chair for the "table" all against a red background produces a vibrant, colorful image. Add to that your arrangement of the elements, which adds a lot of interest, and this is just an outstanding shot.

Memories of Grandad
by dswann

Comment:
Not only does this have technical excellence, it has strong emotive impact.