Music from the rooftops
by Neat

Comment:
Great concept, but to me it looks just too dark - perhaps just the monitor...

Book Review
by sfalice

Comment:
Ah, my favorite composer - PDQ Bach!
The entire shot is fill the frame, except for that triangular "hole" in the upper left...

Newborn
by gyaban

Comment:
I like your use of red/orange as a unifying theme.

Get out of the.....
by Giles

Comment:
No comments - probably because it comes across as a meh picture. It soft-of falls into the "What is it?" category, and with the word being mostly upside down, requires some effort and thought to figure out. Then, there is no real relation between the word and the image.
For me, the technicals are good, but there is no clear meaning or message, so it is hard to relate to.

Message edited by author 2012-02-03 11:40:30.

Friends
by J-Me

Comment:
Somehow the cat's expression brings to mind Garfield...

Own a house by the water
by whiterook

Comment:
Nice photo. Look at all the 5's (and non-trivial number of 6's). I think the lack of immediate connection to the challenge title is what hurt your score. You might take a look at a crop just inside the buoys - it would be less panoramic, but really wouldn't take anything away from the shot. Good work!

Memory
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
Hope this does well for you!

Finger + Nose
by IAmEliKatz

Comment:
Looks like at least 7, and maybe as many as 25... At least nothing is dangling or drooping... ;-P

Christmas Tree
by whiterook

Comment:
As I'm sure you discovered, glass globes are very difficult to get a good picture of. However, you got a great picture of this one! I think the shot would have been more effective if you'd set the globe on the white cloth used for the background, made the background smooth (the wrinkles / folds detract a lot), and kept the near side of the base in the frame. My wife tells me that you should only trim a subject symmetrically - that is, if you crop off part of the object on the bottom, you should also crop a bit off the top too - same for both sides, rather than just one.

Echoes of a Summer Conversation
by tanguera

Comment:
Very nice emotive capture. It revives memories of a past never experienced, precisely, but that lives in our "nice times" department.