Falling
by heida

Comment:
nice pose and comp, but quality seems very off.

The legs look kind of bumpy & Jarred around the edges. Perhaps a little too much D&B for my tastes. With B&W it works well but sometimes excessive dodging & burning can make it look too artificial.

still it's an 8, just trying to give a little critique of something that will probably get 99% positives.

Pinned
by movieman

Comment:
very nice. probably not for DPC, but excellent nevertheless.

The Journalist
by Imagineer

Comment:
Awesome photograph John.

Can't understand why on earth this didn't hit 7+

slightly sub'ed coloring is just, well, apt & sublime

Edited to remove my original swearing - oops


Message edited by author 2004-10-06 16:33:54.

Police Lineup
by TooCool

Comment:

Originally posted by micknewton: I would have given it a 4 or 5. The challenge stated "whole words", and I don't see any, and the selective desaturation gimmick doesn't help this photo in any way.

Really? I see 4 complete words of POLICE

2 on the screens and 2 above the wheels.

A love hate relationship!
by ConcreteDonkey

Comment:
A little like on I did ;)

//www.dpchallenge.com/image.php?IMAGE_ID=75921

Well taken, I like top see bit more contrast

Flow, the book
by pbaarn

Comment:
nice nice idea! A 2nd C flash would have stopped the action and still kept the nice blur lines.

You want a Prince, You Gotta...
by Skip

Comment:
nice idea, but not too well taken. Frogs are looking away and lots of noise / shadow around the left lower frog which looks like it's been missed in post editing.

Sweet reading
by xoao

Comment:
well taken, I imagine it will do well. I have seen it far too many times myself though, a very common photograph. But well taken, and it may not eb common to you.

A Daring Escape
by scalvert

Comment:
Sublime idea, just perfect. 10!!!

freedom of expression!
by theodor38

Comment:
Easily the best pic of the challenge - well composed and extreamly good lighting. Dramtic and effective. 10 and I hope / think you will win!