Icicle Magic
by basssman7

Comment:
I love the shapes and forms in the water ... I think I would like this one even more without the icicle!

Majesty
by AP

Comment:
Beautiful duotone; the detail on the water and the soft tones on the distant mountains are great.

First Come, First Served
by 1m1A

Comment:
Humor - 10. Photo - 1. Challenge - 3.

Go Ahead - Make her day... the Mercedes-Benz Way
by dtremain

Comment:
Angle is too confusing, not sure which car we're looking at, and both the reflections on the hood and the bright plastic bow detract from the image imo. 3

Runs, Has Heat, 100 Bucks
by liberty

Comment:
The lighting is too harsh, and the angle does nothing for me. I'd like to see more of this old beater before laying out a C-note for it! 3.

In fifty years your today’s Mercedes will still look this brilliant
by HighNooner

Comment:
OK .. I'm grading this challenge on a curve, and this was one of the few 3s I gave out. It probably should be a 4, maybe even a 5, because the lighting on the car is nice. But the guardrail in the front is very distracting, and with the door open on the other side of the car it looks like we're missing out on too much. So why is it a 3? Because it is, hands down, the best looking car in the challenge, and there is so much more that could have been done with such a wonderful subject, imo. OK, maybe that's not fair. 4.

Anonymousgetawayvehicles.com - Cash only
by raish

Comment:
Just a snapshot that doesn't say anything to me about the cars. Cutting the front of the first one in the row out brings this down, as does the scaffolding in the background. Maybe shot from a little more to the left in front of the car would have worked better. 4

Ford Trucks - Tough & In Your Face!
by trevytrev

Comment:
Nice motion blur and good sharp focus on the Ford logo here. The antenna cut out at the top of the frame is a little annoying, because it draws my eye up and out of the image. 6

Toy for every age "Hummer H2"
by FocusPoint

Comment:
Lighting is a bit harsh, and the flat two-dimensional angle doesn't bring out the from of the car. Just a 4 from me.

Business. Class. BMW.
by h2

Comment:
Reflections on the windshields are distracting, and the background makes this look just like a snapshot. Sorry. 4