Peek-A-Boo
by Kimber90

Comment:
On my monitor it looks like the focus was a little long (on the books). I think this would have been a very good shot but the lighting is harsh and the table cutting through their eyes looks weird instead of interesting. I think if you could have had them come up a little so they had 4 eyes it would have been better at least in my opinion. Idea and composition are both great.

The light of Knowledge
by saurongt

Comment:
Interesting perspective (which is the idea right?). One of my favorites so far. I love the blown out window at the end and also the isles..kinda weird I know. Anyway this is a wonderful photo, thanks. One negative for me is that it seems like the left books are softer focus than the right? That is probably just an optical illusion.

The Last Breakfast
by Sand-Strider

Comment:
Well, at least you got a free movie with your last meal. Looks like a fun shoot, good job. I wished there was a little more separation between the model and background....kinda blends in. I like the perspective very much.

The road
by Leoo

Comment:
I bet you are getting a lot of DNMC because of the "place it on a table top" sentence. I think you should really gained back any deducts with the "The idea is to get a photograph from an alternate perspective not normally viewed" aspect of your shot. It is a great sky and perspective but the dark trees aren't too attractive for me. I think it would have been more interesting for me if I could see the road vanishing and especially the curve in the road shown more. 5

"Tippy Toes"
by Tia2QQ

Comment:
Very cute and original. Meets the challenge perfectly. I love the composition but would like to mention a couple of things that would have made it a 10 for me. First I would like to have seen better symetry on the girl and her reflection, at least both eyes in the reflection. Next I would love for this to break the rules and be perfectly centered. Lastly I would have liked it sharper in the eyes. Very good shot..8

Yellow Rainbow
by behemoth

Comment:
I bet if I went back and looked at all the colored pencil shots I've voted on they would all be at or above an 8. I don't know why I like them so much. Anyway I really like yours too. 9

Landed
by bubeltrubel

Comment:
Wow, now that is shallow with good subject definition. Well done.

Graveyard Gooseberries
by labuds

Comment:
Wonderful lighting and dof. 10

Delight of the Bee
by SandyP

Comment:
I voted 5 at first look and then found the bee.....I'm now bumping it up to 7, but I think it would have been a 9 or 10 if the bee was closer to the focused flower. There is just too much space between subjects. Great shot though and great timing.

Please
by alfresco

Comment:
Wow, that is some great color. Great focus too. 10, but I really would have like to seen all the stamen in focus :) To shallow, to shallow!