Water Lilies
by posthumous

Comment:
OK I have to be honest and say that this image really doesnt do it for me. I confess I nearly auto reacted and hit a 2, but then considered that although i may not be to my taste - fortunately for the world - I am not the arbiter of what is good and what isnt and I reckon there will be some people who love this. It meets the challenge in an interesting and unique way. Not something that I would really enjoy looking at for a period of time but there are qualities in it.

Waiting for the green light
by edmeng

Comment:
Great entry for the challenge and a truly magnificent B&W conversion. Has the air of a Robert Doisneau image of emotions caught candidly

Outstanding 9

dine
by nixter

Comment:
Beautiful range of shapes wonderfully captured. Great B&W conversion and fantastic POV. One of those images that smacks the senses when you see it on screen. A superb 9

London, July 2007
by e301

Comment:
And police are once again proved useless as the worlds worst pickpocket springs into action!!!!

Great and intriguing image from one of my favourite areas of London. Good B&W conversion

Three in the Rain
by tonyv

Comment:
Marmite picture....In that people are either going to love it or hate it.

I fall into the former camp but I hope that you realise that your score in this challenge is unlikely to represent the true worth of this shot. Brave clever and unique

Sysiphus
by Oded

Comment:
The rock may be invisible but the back breaking years of the challenge of taking it to the top of the mountain is apparent

Great image and wonderful complimentary title

The Blanton Arches
by nadiaC

Comment:
Lovely architecture and the person half appearing (and I am guessing from the pose on a mobile phone) gives it great context. Super continuation of the pathway in the open space beyong the arches. Good B&W conversion although to me the horizontal seems slightly off on the shot which is a tad distracting. This could well be the way the arches/pathway are shaped (and if it is I apologise) but if you look at the rear most arch it looks somewhat askew

Camera Shy
by ltaylor

Comment:
Lovely image although it leaves me wondering how successful what I guess is a buggy to take tourists round an area could be when the streets seem so deserted

Walk to Sulfer Mountain Lookout
by admart01

Comment:
Wow, stunning landscape and a very good take on the challenge. One of those pictures that makes me envious that I have not had the good fortune to visit this place

Alone in a Busy World
by Agaeris

Comment:
Very very clever desat and truly excellent contrasting element image. The chap on the outside feels wonderfully isolated. Outstanding 9