There Can Be Only One
by neophyte

Comment:
First Impression:one what
Presentation:ok
What I Like:nothing
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:everything
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: poor
Background : out of focus
Subject Placement: bad I am not sure what the subject is
Cropping:bad
Focus: excellent on the headlight poor on the rest
Exposure: highlights blown
Editing:

Total Averaged Rating :5

The reindeer
by sz1_

Comment:
First Impression: looks like a poster
Presentation: good
What I Like: the colours
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:the stick in the foreground
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: Fair
Background : did you try a different view point to try and escape some of the untidy back ground.
Subject Placement: a bit obscured by the grass
Cropping:fair
Focus: slightly soft
Exposure: good
Editing: fair

Total Averaged Rating : 7

Bancroft Mill Steam Engine
by TacTZilla

Comment:
First Impression: looks like an olden day industrial image
Presentation: good
What I Like:the focal point
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:nothing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good the figures in the background give a sense of scale. good motion blur from moving parts
Background : good
Subject Placement:v good
Cropping:good
Focus: good
Exposure:good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :7

Devotion
by gloda

Comment:
First Impression: cute
Presentation:good
What I Like: i am a sucker for animals1
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: nothing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background : v good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: good
Focus: slightly soft on the bottom animal
Exposure:good
Editing: good
Total Averaged Rating :7

Silhouette
by doug61853

Comment:
First Impression: Not another nude!
Presentation: good
What I Like:that it is a silhouette
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:that it is not a proper silhouette
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: fair
Background :good
Subject Placement:good
Cropping:should have cropped above the little black triangle bottom right
Focus: ok
Exposure:ok
Editing:ok

Total Averaged Rating :6

Village Life
by SaraR

Comment:
First Impression: A good candid image of village life
Presentation:fair
What I Like: the atmosphere of this image
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:The white line at the bottom
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good but iwould have liked the two to be interacting with each other.
Background : good
Subject Placement:good
Cropping: cropped too close to the feet.
Focus: slightly soft
Exposure:good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :7

marsh
by annakiya33

Comment:
First Impression:
Presentation:
What I Like:inclusion of the old railroad
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:burnt out sky
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :
Subject Placement:good leads one into the distance
Cropping:good
Focus: good
Exposure:the foreground is fine but the sky has burnt out maybe an ND filter would have helped
Editing:

Total Averaged Rating :6

Autumn Morning
by hahn23

Comment:
First Impression:
Presentation:Good
What I Like:A beautiful scene
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: nothing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :good
Subject Placement:good
Cropping: good
Focus: good
Exposure:good
Editing:

Total Averaged Rating :9

Unwind
by WalesP

Comment:
First Impression:
Presentation:
What I Like: it is amazing that such simple props could make such an effective image
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:nothing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: vgood
Background :vgood
Subject Placement:vgood
Cropping:vgood
Focus: good
Exposure:good
Editing:basic

Total Averaged Rating :9

curves of her life
by AreEx

Comment:
First Impression:
Presentation:good
What I Like: the idea this could have been a winner if you had taken more time to get it
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: exposure the tree and rail on the right
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :overexposed
Subject Placement:good
Cropping:fair
Focus: good
Exposure:overexposed
Editing:basic

Total Averaged Rating :6