Three Amigos
by pawdrix

Comment:
First Impression: too much going on
Presentation:good
What I Like: the idea
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: it would have been better in colour and there is some flair or reflection behind the pumkin on the right.
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: would have been better if the cat was looking at you.
Background :messy
Subject Placement: good
Cropping:I would have cropped the distracting cushions out
Focus: patchy some very sharp
Exposure:good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :6

pOLY
by Kronus

Comment:
First Impression:Nice macaw
Presentation:good
What I Like: the detail in his feathers
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background : v good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: a little too tight
Focus: v good
Exposure:v good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :9

waiting for a gust of wind
by Amason

Comment:
First Impression: what beautiful light
Presentation: good
What I Like: the light the moody sky
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :good
Subject Placement:good
Cropping: good
Focus: good
Exposure: good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :9

Watchful Eye
by menele

Comment:
First Impression: nice animal portrait
Presentation: good
What I Like: out focus back ground
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: no eye contact with photographer
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: if you could have got another view point you might have got a bit of eye contact
Background : excellent
Subject Placement: fair
Cropping: good
Focus: eyes are abit soft otherwise good
Exposure: good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :8

Water Lily
by briandsd

Comment:
First Impression: lovely colours
Presentation: good
What I Like: the colour
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:the dark gaps
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: I think this would have worked better as a half flower
Background : shouldn't show
Subject Placement:ok
Cropping:should have been tighter
Focus: good
Exposure:good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :7

Kiss the Sun
by smellyfish1002

Comment:
First Impression: too dark and overpowering
Presentation: good
What I Like: the concept
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: the darkness
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background : good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: a bit too tight
Focus: ok
Exposure: too dark I know it is meant to be a silhouette
Editing: ok

Total Averaged Rating :6

Nuthatch
by JustinM

Comment:
First Impression: nice record shot
Presentation: good
What I Like: the way the branch partially frames the image
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: the lighting is harsh
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: nicely composed
Background : good
Subject Placement: a little too central but good
Cropping: good
Focus: good
Exposure: too brightly lit has blown the light feathers
Editing: good

Total Averaged Rating :7

imperial moth at night
by yanko

Comment:
First Impression: a visitor from outer space
Presentation:fair
What I Like:the catch lights
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: you've cut two of his feet off
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background : good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: a bit too tight
Focus: excellent macro
Exposure:good
Editing: good

Total Averaged Rating :

Oh, had I the wings of a dove
by Bruce_the_Robert

Comment:
First Impression: a beautiful bird image
Presentation: good
What I Like: the sharp focus on the feathers
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: The dark splodges at the bottom
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :would have been better if you could have got just blue sky.
Subject Placement:good
Cropping:good
Focus: excellent
Exposure: v good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :6

Wisconsin River 9/26/07
by eamurdock

Comment:
First Impression:a record image of a bush
Presentation: good
What I Like:The out of focus back ground
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: It is rather boring
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: fair
Background : good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: good
Focus: good
Exposure: good
Editing: good

Total Averaged Rating :5