Y
by BlueZamia

Comment:
love the earthy quality of this - the offset positioning really adds to the image

Y
by bvlindalou

Comment:
love the sway of this one - the sky really complements the Y

A
by bvlindalou

Comment:
great colors here - the reds are so vibrant and the clouds in the background really add to the image - there is a bit of noise in the background

O
by UNCLEBRO

Comment:
your conversion to b/w is excellent but I agree that it is not as tack sharp as the rest of your images - but in a collage you would never notice

F
by UNCLEBRO

Comment:
the details and textures really complement the wonderful greys in this b/w image - well done

Glow
by noraneko

Comment:
catherine - such a beautiful image - the details and colors are so rich and the composition is so simple yet perfectly harmonized

DENALI
by Emerkaza

Comment:
Fantastic photo - love the clarity and crispness of this image. The trees in the foreground really provide some excellent depth to the photo. Gave it a 7 during the challenge for the shear quality of the image, but it really doesn't scream rural to me - rather is would likely win in a remote or natural landscape.

Between the Spaces
by unknowndeath

Comment:
i really liked the rural village feel of this image. the dirt road and the hills and mountains in the background make it obvious to me i would have liked a more interesting sky, but you can't have everything! gave it a 7 during the challenge

sacred church
by unknowndeath

Comment:
good sky but the power lines are a significant distraction

back for a followup after your PM about the powerlines - I have looked again and tried to understand where you are going. There is some subtle connection of the lines and there sweep to the arches of the church. However, the title really doesn't tell the audience that the powerlines are intentional. If the title were something like "Sacred Lines", I would have likely got it.

Sorry, but even with a better understanding, it will still get a 5 from me.

Time to Oneself
by redmoon

Comment:
this is SOOOO close - I just don't like the centered composition - placing the person off centered at one of the thirds would make this image so much more dramatic IMO