Breakfast aromas
by train

Comment:
This is one heck of a shot and a great interpretation of the challenge. A couple of things kept it from getting my highest mark. Focus from front to back needs to be consistent. It looks like it may have been over sharpened. The rim on the coffee cup and saucer are ragged (on my screen). You evoked a sencse of smell in my nose immediately. Steam riseing from the food would have tweaked an aditional sense of aroma. You still got good marks from me. Is that scene off your deck? Best of luck.

Isopropyl
by GeneralE

Comment:
I thought this was a very common, but at the same time unique, interpretation of the challenge. Common in that almost everyone has experienced this smell. I wish that the hand (your hand? If so a model might have helped) came more out of the left and did not take up so much of the subject. Also, it is under exposed somewhat and a little too grainnie. I realize I have made several criticisms but they are are offered in the most constructive of spirit. Best of luck.

onions on the grill
by coolhar

Comment:
I wanted so much to rate this even higher than what I did. The clarity of the shot is great. But my mind kept saying there was something missing. . . LIVER!!!! I know everytime I order liver and onions I see eyes roll and noses go up! At any rate, best of luck.

smells like winter
by ursula

Comment:
While this was without a doubt one of the most fantastic pictures in this challenge, I could not rate it at its highest. . . simply because I could not make a quick connection to the theme of the challenge. I am sure there are scents and aromas that are here, but in my estimation too many. But then again, that is just me. Best of luck

Smells Bad... Tastes Worse... Open up!
by space amoeba

Comment:
This picture, while super, does not convey the message of the title. In my humble opinion, it would have been enhanced greatly if a title was included right in the picture which could be read. For example: a cod liver oil label.

Incense Holy Scent
by acquaresegone

Comment:
While I found most shots with flowers and smoking scents to be just ordinary shots, yours was the exception to the rule. The combination of subjects and the composition, along with the colors set yours apart. You got a higher mark from me. Best of luck.

Just For Men!
by agwright

Comment:
Very sharp shot. What I like about it best is what is not in focus! Adds a bit of question to the composition while the subject still gets my attention for it clarity.

Fresh Homemade Bread
by melking

Comment:
Mom?!

Scents of Yesteryear
by jpb323red

Comment:
Hey, That looks like my wife's dresser!!!!! Are you a collector? Wondering why you didn't submit this in color. I realize you were lookiing for the yesteryear look but I would imagine there was some beautiful color here. Also, would have liked to have seen the top off of one bottle to suggest fragrance escaping. Maybe the one at the left laid across the top of the bottle. Just my opinion though. best of luck.

FESTIVE SMELL
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
911