Fall Reflections
by Kelli

Comment:
I guess that new popup message asking for comments on scores below 4 isn't working. Six people owe you comments as to why they thought your entry sucked. I don't agree with those ratings. I like this and agree with Kivet that the sky is probably what hurt this. But skies can be fixed with advanced editing. Unfortunately, one thing that can't be fixed in post processing is the straight line of the shore that cuts the photo in half. Still I like the shot, especially the little picnic table.

colorado river
by griz210

Comment:
I was noticing the lack of comments, then I noticed you didn't even comment yourself.:) The lone commenter said the color and contrast were the problem. I think it is the light. The foreground has no interesting light on it. With advanced editing, you might be able to do something about that. You have a beautiful scene and composition to work with.

Message edited by author 2006-12-08 11:48:42.

Ode to Joy
by Melethia

Comment:
I didn't leave a comment, just a very high score. Didn't really know what to say except that it is spectacular.

Airborne
by xianart

Comment:
You've done it again -- captured a great shot of that wonderful little model. The shot of him sitting on the path is still fresh in my mind, and I love the shot you call 'swagger'.

The setting in this shot is perfect: the window with the broken screen, the ramp, and the shingles. So uplifting to see the joy of simple physical play in this age of electronic toys.

Into the Woods
by Elaine

Comment:
While I think this is a very nice composition, for some reason I'm not drawn into the shot. It may be that it is a little flat. Perhaps a touch of Image>Adjustment>Exposure (offset and gamma) would improve that.

Liberty at Sunset
by levyj413

Comment:
I've never used a gradient map. I'll have to experiment, if this it what it can do.

Illusions of Self
by posthumous

Comment:
This must be the shot that inspired the topic for the current challenge "For Sale".

Potter Street Station
by bmartuch

Comment:
I like this and gave it an 8. I think I would like it even better if the sky weren't such a flat gray. That seems to flatten the entire image. Did you ever experiment with Filter>Render>Clouds? Take a look at what that does. And please pardon me if I have taken too much liberty with your art.

Peacock Love
by noraneko

Comment:
These birds are lovely and the pose is touching. The light is good. I gave it a 6, and I am trying to understand why it is lacking in impact. I think it is the green background. The peahen's colors are so soft that I think the green overpowers her. Also her topknot is not standing out well against the green. Really nice shot though.

Do you believe in afterlife?
by MattO

Comment:
Very well done!