New Farm Park Tree's
by Pompouspete

Comment:
Not sure if you're in the wrong challenge - this would make sense in the old.

As for the image - the lighting being so harsh creates nice shadows on the tree, but blows out the sky.

1880
by brettt83

Comment:
So Australian!

Vintage Sound: 1941 Reslo RV Ribbon Microphone
by shamer

Comment:
Great subject. A bit more brightness would have worked for me.

partying in an old theatre
by takinou42

Comment:
Sensational photo - I just love it. But I must say it's stretching it for the challenge.

As in image I think it ROCKS! Love the lighting and B&W.

280 dog years left behind...
by liskro

Comment:
The image is not working. The lighting and position mean that we cannot clearly see the features of this 'dog'. It just looks like a blob with the smallest suggestion of an eye and tongue. Lack of clarity really means the subject is lost.

Classic Nude
by thedarkpose

Comment:
Interesting nude and shiny too. The crop is too extreme in my opinion.

In addition I can see that you're trying to come from left of centre of the topic, but I feel this does not really meet the spirit of the challenge as you're not showing me anything 'old'.

Old man
by rami

Comment:
Beautiful subject, great face. Unfortunately the lighting is against you and it appears you may have rushed taking the image.

Antiques
by fotofan

Comment:
Looks like a funky building. The lighting seemed to be against you and I wonder if that was the reason behind your unusual cropping choice?

Old town
by Rino63

Comment:
I think the location is great, but for this challenge the inclusion of modern artifacts looses the spirit for me. I'm really not fond of the juxtaposition of the woman on the phone, nor the sign of to the right. Also the poles in the planters look horrid. I think another point of view of the building would have been best.

these old gloves of mine
by SherwinJames

Comment:
Brilliant! Love the idea, subject, perspective and texture -great tones and hues - just GREAT!