Molly
by benhur

Comment:
A beloved pet is a good subject for a personal triptych, but I think to appeal to the casual viewer these need to be better technically. A full body shot, maybe running or in some other action, would have added variety. The photo on the left isn't very sharp, and in the top right photo the flash seems very harsh.

Making Waves
by rosiehall

Comment:
There's a lot of empty space in this triptych, and barely any variety in the three chosen photos. The shadow at the bottom of each photo could probably have been cropped out, too, bringing the viewer closer to the splashes.

Roadside stand
by SDW

Comment:
Your idea is fine for a triptych, but the varying focal points are really odd. I think the cartons don't help your composition, either.

Grieving gelding
by snaffles

Comment:
I'm sorry to hear the horse is grieving, but aside from the caption this doesn't grab my attention. I also think the blue frame is a terrible aesthetic choice, both for the color (it doesn't go with the subject; an earth-tone would probably be better) and composition-wise.

Decline
by eamurdock

Comment:
A fine subject for a triptych, and I like the black background, but none of the photos are in focus, which spoils your efforts.

Spring Flowers
by Shea927

Comment:
Intentionally soft or out-of-focus? Since I have no way of knowing, I'll have to assume it is unintentional, sorry.

Go!
by cirus

Comment:
I don't mind that you have four photos in a triptych, but you get a "3" for laziness! Why have more than one photo if they all are the same? Four shots of the same car, from the same tourist-stance angle, taken at pretty much the same time (judging by the people in the background). If the car is moving it doesn't show, and if it is standing still than why not get a little creative: show a close-up of the number, or the driver, or the hubcup? This doesn't *reveal* anything. Sorry if I sound harsh, but I know you can do better than this, whoever you are! :-)

he sleeps well
by sher

Comment:
Beautiful triptych. Each photo stands on its own, yet they work well together. Connected thematically and visually, yet with enough variety to warrant their inclusion. A 10 from me and one of my top two favorites in the challenge. Good luck!

Sunrise Waves
by hotpasta

Comment:
On first round, I give this best in show! The b&w has depth and adds to the mood (it seems like so many times it is used in an attempt to make art out of a bad photo). A strong 10 from me. Good luck!

Edit: Yup, best in show, with "he sleeps well" a close second. I'm sure you'll both do well.

Hells Kitchen
by MAK

Comment:

Originally posted by MAK: ... the fact that this shot received 5 X 1s to me, does not show a simple dislike of the cartoon editing but more of an attempt to lower the end result thus known as TROLLING. A vote of 1 should be issued to a shot that is 160x160 pixels totally void of any connection to the challenge without any focus whatsoever. ... etc.

MAK, I hope there aren't people who intentionally vote low when they recognize a style ("trolling")... and I certainly hope there aren't five! I think it's more likely that people saw something they hated, or thought they should hate: the presence of food, the presence of humor, the presence of a style of post-processing they don't like... who knows?

I agree with you completely about the kind of photo that deserves a 1, by the way. It looks like a lot of good photographers have to suffer idiot voters. C'est la vie dp, apparently!