MegaGrowth
by Rohn

Comment:
The produc looks like it is floating - separate from the background - thereby makeing the two planes disconnected. I'm not sure what waterlillies has to do with MegaGrowth, but the two elements don't work very well together.

Abstracts, Spring Catalogue, Page 7
by bspurgeon

Comment:
And another collusury non-product product shot. This idea of the image itself as the product, I can't seem to make fit the challenge. Additionally, I feel as though I now need to vote otwards a collective instead of an individual submission. I think this was a poor idea to team up for submissions on this challenge. I try to vote the images independently, but it is difficult when they are submitted as a team.

Handcrafted Lagers & Ales
by Keith_W

Comment:
Good idea, love the base/backdrop. The lighting reflections and glare hurt this a bit and the frame seems a bit tilted.

Tabasco- made with peppers
by kellmak10

Comment:
Brilliant! This is my favorite in the challenge. Sharpening is a bit overdone, especially on the printed letters.

Citizen DIve Watch
by bob_bobski

Comment:
Decent shot, but there are some dust specs on the glass that should've been cleaned up. The typo in the title would refect badly on the catalog as well.

Use #174
by MargaritaLibrarian

Comment:
Good idea. There is something odd looking about the toe that draws my eye. Not sure what it is, though

Abstract, Spring Catalogue - Pg. 42
by krnodil

Comment:
And yet another in this collusury effort. This woudl be decent in an abstract challenge, not a Product Shot though.

Catalogue Abstrait du Printemps - p. 13 "lutte avec des forces plus grandes"
by posthumous

Comment:
And yet another in this collusury effort. I ask myself "what product does this represent?" Making the abstract submission the product itself seems quite a stretch for the challenge.

It's a nice image, but I don't think it fits the challenge. Probably would've scored better in the fine arts challenge

C905 - The Cat and the Canary Bookends -- $14.95
by vawendy

Comment:
The books are more interesting than the product(s) - which is largely invisible in the shot. The sharpening is a it over-the-top as well. Lvoe the books though.

Abstracts, Spring Catalogue, Page 500
by hihosilver

Comment:
Odd title as this isn't really abstract. I can make out the object - a ring, and the words - Tiffany, so I wouldn't consider it abstract.

There seem to be a number of these - a collusury effort it seems - same title, different pages. That doesn't garner any additional points and makes me think this is less of an individual effort.