boy in the rain
by holbein

Comment:
One of my few 10s in this challenge. This really meets the challenge well. I love the sel desat. This is an award winning photograph! 10

Fawn Shaftail
by JuliBoc

Comment:
Wow! Magnificent detail and colors.

Red-Shouldered Hawk and Angry Crow
by Germaine

Comment:
Great nature capture.

1945 in the outskirts of Warsaw: War is over
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
I don't know what those red things are. But, the rest of the image has great gravitas. 10

How far do raindrops fall?
by RaeK

Comment:
Love it! 10

Point of View
by gyaban

Comment:
It's a beautiful image, but it's not photographic in nature. By that, I mean one would never see this with one's eyes. It's a joy to view, but it's pure fantasy. Since this is an expert edit challenge, I will mark this 10, but I don't accept it as a photograph. Really enjoy your ability to draw and paint. No offense intended.

Just One of Those Days
by Judi

Comment:
Fantastic! 10

Honeysuckle
by Kelli

Comment:
A very pretty flower and foliage. Shallow DOF, which does throw the attention to the blossoms. Not sure about the lavender-ish toning. But, it's okay.

Southport Spit at sunrise.
by thrumyiis

Comment:
A bit stark. I do like the foreground vegetation. I think this needs another element of interest.

dogspray falls
by daisydavid

Comment:
From a tonal range point of view, this is good. I do see detail in the dark shadows.