Mystical Shadows
by blacjack

Comment:
very nice. transformative.

Romance
by grigrigirl

Comment:
excellent. I'm always excited to see the next grigrigirl shot! :)

Guardian of the Cross
by BAMartin

Comment:
Greetings from Critique Club!

I gave this a 6. Really it was a 6 and a half, very close to a 7. I like the simplicity of this image. The "lost" details and "blown" highlights on the church work nicely, imho. My only problem with the image is the pigeon, actually. I just want him to be a bit more vivid, or stand out in some way. Is that a shadow on his neck? I don't like that much. I also wonder if a square crop might have accentuated the iconic quality of this image.

Nicely seen and captured. Thank you!

Harbour Life
by Nuzzer

Comment:
Welcome to Your Tit-for-tat Critique Club Critique!

The gods have given me my opportunity for revenge! ;)

Firstly, I have to be honest with you. I only gave you a 5. The good news is that most skylines get a 4 from me because I find them boring. Yours got an extra point for the exciting motion of light in the water. In fact, if I had looked at this picture more carefully, I probably would have given it a 6.

Technically, you are past my level, so I have no fixes for this. The horizon is straight enough, the exposure is good, the focus is good, you managed to keep still for 25 seconds. You seem aware of the inherent boringness of cityscapes, so you captured the motion on the bottom and emphasized the tower on the top. Good thinking. I wonder if that helicopter would have added interest? Or if you could have emphasized the stars? The more the merrier for a shot like this. maybe a tighter crop would have worked nicely, as someone else suggested.

fruit and vegetables too
by charliebaker

Comment:
This is tragic. You were outbrowned by a newbie with natural talent. For what it's worth, I don't think my 10 counted since your picture was the only one I voted on. :D

Nice Ice
by pixelpig

Comment:
very cool photo!! I love it.

Ice
by BBBastet

Comment:
very nice photo. good eye.

Tear Drops
by meow

Comment:
lovely.

Snow and Lights
by stare_at_the_sun

Comment:
very cool photo.

Winter's Heartless Daggers
by elizadeb

Comment:
great shot! It should have scored higher.