An Apple a Day Keeps the Doctor Away
by jdincolsprings

Comment:
The medicine bottles are a little too out of focus. llike the browning to the apple, good effect. Sharper medical bottles would have been a 7 but can't possible give nore than a 5 to 5.5 as it is. Better luck next time.

Halloween
by lochiano

Comment:
What is the red drawing on the table or whatever? It is distracting Can't tell what is supposed to be under pentagon on left as looking at it and is that supposed to be lifesavers on top of the star? Poor lighting, for focus. Back shadowing around edge. Going some to give it a 4 even.

Fractured Feline
by spiderman

Comment:
A broken mirror reflecting a picture of a cat, right? Just doesn't get it for me. Dull colors, too busy. ABout the best I can give a 1 point for each cat I see which is 3

Thank you Lady Luck!
by Manic

Comment:
Ever noticed how "luck" is a lady no matter what country you are in. Pretty good photo. I don't understand your choice of lighting but it does add mistique. Do feel there is going to be disagreement on your choice of focus point. But for me it is fine. Not exciting but a good shot.

High Beams
by takethat

Comment:
Didn't know there was a "legend" with headlight. And sure can't come up with a superstition. I always just use my makeup mirror and shine them back in their own eyes. Can't figure out what is to the boy's right. Hope you tell us. Otherwise a fairly good shot with the light source where it is. Pretty good.

Good Thing I Can't Read Yet!
by GeneralE

Comment:
Don't like the lines on the wall. They ruin the whole thing. Why is everyone cropping so closely. That makes me crop my scores too. Cropped you down to a 5

bad luck
by jcof

Comment:
Too much empty space. Is that cat on a car? What is that in front of the car(?)? Is that a katsup squirt bottle. Bad surface cat is standing on. Can't possible give more than 3 even though it is in focus.

The Sad End of Another Night Forever
by amonteforte

Comment:
The idea takes a minute to register - you have to see that one tooth to catch it. Before that the pimples and black heads catch your eye and turn you off. I didn't even see the eyes until about the third or forth close up look. Photo wise it is fairly decent maybe a 5 - a little tightly cropped, a little too dark even for the subject it is, to dark a shadow on the other eye and neck. But eye appeal, for me, knocks it down some.

Find a penny, pick it up. All the day, you'll have good luck.
by falvey

Comment:
Is this laying on a drainage grate in the street? Neet shot right down to texture being almost 3-D. Even to the flaws on the penny. Good 8.

Demon Snail Pumpkin of Sierra Madre
by JEFFCOWLES

Comment:
I want to see this one with out the effects. Just a plain old lights on sitting on the kitchen table picture. This one has me buffaloed. The carving itself is worth the 8. Took someone some time to do this. So it rates a 9