Merry Xmoose
by camelotnorth

Comment:
4 candy canes and 4 Christmas ornaments. Yep, met the challenge. Good composition, good crop, good clear focus, nice background. Yep, met the requirements for technically good photo. Seasonal subject, cute and cuddly. Yet, met requirements for personal appeal. Only thing missing for a 10 is the "Wow". Must be an 8. And a good one, too. PTL

444
by whaler

Comment:
No body can deny you met the challenge. Why didn't you tune the radio to 4? I know because the stations start at 5.? right. Your FM numbers are blown out by the flash and it's a little dark on the name at the top. But otherwise ok. Nice 6 is fair for this. PTL

Put Your Tiny Paw in Mine
by magnetic9999

Comment:
This print is so clear I can see his/her paw print (fingerprints) clearly. Looks like a tiny baby's. Does "it" have a body and name to go with it? My only complaint is that maybe you should have put it on a different colored blanket, a soft color, so the white fur would show better. And that's not a complaint, just a thought. Really, what is it? Good shot and I like it enough to give it a 7. PTL Might have been higher if the whole body had been there, but the challenge was 4. (4 feet)

Paws Four Thought
by cdhuk

Comment:
Come on now. No teasing. The fur is beautiful. I want to see the whole cat. Is it a blue point? I know the "4" paws, but they do have a cat attached. For the paws you get a 7, where as the cat would have gotten a 9 or 10. Sorry. PTL

Eagles
by BeeGee

Comment:
Great looking building with 4 great birds. Beautiful sky and I love the contrast of the sun on the building with the shaded parts. This is really good. I know you cropped for the birds, but I would like to see what the whole building looks like. Any way this deserves an 8. PTL

Channel 4 Doppler Radar
by alanfreed

Comment:
Awesome photo. I sure hope the radar sees the storm that appears to be coming. But I have a great big question. What are the two grey things sticking up from the bottom of the photo, on each side of the tower. At first I thought it might be a tornadoe trying to form, then it looked like a finger mark on a negative. Now I'm not too sure. But it is really distracting. I'd like to see further down to see what they are. In fact on the left there are actually two of them connect about the second wrung up the tower. I hate this because they knock the score down from a 10 to a 6. And I really like how it looks like a storm coming. PT>

Merry Christmas
by jimmythefish

Comment:
I see it is an upside down 4 and it is also an illusion. Am I supposed to see anything else. I'm not getting the title, unless it's the cross, but that's Easter. The title really doesn't matter in this challenge, "4", but since you did title it, I believe I must see it. Other than not seeing the title, it's probably too clear for me to see, the photo is technically a good B&W. Now you give me a problem as to how to score it. I guess a 6 for the technical part of it. PTL

Four Cubed
by paynekj

Comment:
I am amazed that you did this. Or did you? I really like the composition: the focus, the cropping, the placement. Only thing I question is the background color, with the colors on the cube. It seems to steal your site away from the cube. In my opinion black or maybe a soft or light red or blue would have done better. They wouldn't be so distracting. Other wise good one. I'll still give it an 8. PTL

Candy Canes
by Gekker

Comment:
Too out of focus and I question if they are really candy canes. Home made? Maybe. Sorry but all I can give is a 3. PTL

Pocket Bullets
by pbidgway

Comment:
Something wrong with me. The table seems to be going downhill toward the right. It makes me feel like leaning to veiw the picture. Otherwise it's a good picture. It's still a 6. PTL