My Girls.
by catpixel

Comment:
Georgeous cat. What kind is it. Oh, the woman is pretty too. But, being another woman, I love the cat. Looks very much like my Maine Coon. This is a beautiful shot. Very clean focus. Maybe just a little dark. You shuld have shown a little more of the cat, or was there too much on the table? Would be an 8 in my book. PTL

belly
by shutterfly

Comment:
Nice rose. The colors are a little faded. Too much shadow on the right side, or not enough, depending on what your intention was. The focus is good and the composition is ok, just need better execution. This would be about a 5. PTL

shadow dog
by kenbo

Comment:
Am I seeing things or is your frame thicker on the left bottom than the right bottom, and on the left side more than the right side? It's a very good shadow dog. You should have left the bird or duck out. Also I don't believe you meet the challenge because you didn't show the body part you are making the dog with. I know we all know, but the photo should show it. SO.....I couldn't score you more than a 3. It's also too dark for my likes. PTL

Revealing
by Natasha

Comment:
I hope you explain this one to us. Is this the way the back of a geisha girl looks? The photo is good technically, focus, cropping, framing, etc. I just don't understand what you are saying. Therefore I couldn't score it higher than 5. PTL

A Drink
by mediamst

Comment:
B&W works well here. Only problem I see is you lose your focus on the handd about the end of the thumb. I feel it should be in good focus all the way. Since the bottle is in good focus I'd think this was caused by cropping. Try zooming in closer then when you crop it will be in focus. Just a thought. It's still a good 6. PTL

Bleagh!
by spiderman

Comment:
My reaction exactly, followed by reversing the parastolisysis. This turns my stomach, which might be the reaction you were reaching for. As far as the photo for photography sake goes - the focus is good; cropping is a little tight, you should have shown all of the mouth and mustasche and nose since you showed the chin; coloring - i've never seen a tongue that red unless they've eaten a cherry popsicle. For the challenge I guess it would probably be a 7 by someone else, but by me it would only be a 5. Then I'd go clean up the mess I made. PTL

Froober's Day
by muckpond

Comment:
Interesting photo. I really like the old bathroom. Is this in a home or apartment? Back to the photo. This is different and I like it. Could stand to be a little lighter, but not too much or you'll blow out the wall, tube, and curtain. But does need to be brighter. Otherwise it rates an 8. PTL

Steady Hands
by BAMartin

Comment:
Really nice photo. The tip of the cue stick is a little out of focus, but the rest is right on. Biggest problem is the challenge is "body parts" and the hand is the lest thing in the photo. The hand should be the focal point, not just stuck in on the side, occupying less than 1/10 of the photo. Better photo than challenge meeting. I hope you can understand what I mean. For the challenge I'd have to give it a 4. In another challenge it would be an 8 or 9. PTL

Two by Four, Eight Feet Long
by DougPaz

Comment:
What a sweet family. Somehow got the feet too light. may was too dark and adjusted the gamma too much. If that is the case works better to go one notch on gamma, then use either saturation or brightness to bring rest of the way. That is if that was the problem. Other wise it is a really good photo. Good clear focus, nice cropping. I like the 2 color border; it works well with your colors. This would be an 8 or 9 in my book. PTL

Nipple
by dimitrii

Comment:
This would be a 1. PTL