Chocolate Moose
by idnic

Comment:
maybe just a bit heavy on the sharpening to my eye.

Forest Spirits
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Didn't vote in this challenge but I think this shot was creative, well executed, and without your explanation of 2xRAW conversion would leave me wondering how you held the detail in the hilight areas and the shadows. The green foliage is a perfect complement to the warm tones in the bagged candles. If there is one suggestion I would make it would be to have placed another semi-obscured bag deeper into the BG to enhance the feeling of wanting to follow the lights to their begining.

Remember only you can prevent forest fires.

Nailed by voters
by edmeng

Comment:
2, just joking

Extinguishing
by soup

Comment:
Congrats,

I only voted on one image in this challenge, yours. Started to browse thumbs one day and this one caught my eye, gave it a nine and never had time to go back and vote for all of the others. Gave it a 9 and its cool to see it in blue. (good choice of color, haha)

evie_W_CRW_5590-copy.jpg
by Prof_Fate

Comment:
This picture makes me feel cold, seeing her expression and the coldness on her face. Good job making the viewer feel the freeze. I think I would prefer a slightly offcenter position but thats jmo.

berries-white-IMG_2217.jpg
by Bear_Music

Comment:
a taste of whats to come? NPI

Why Bother?
by runin2dson

Comment:
nice job. I didnt vote on this challenge but looks like a 7-8 to me. Great finish.

mark

Nativity
by Glou

Comment:
personal viewpoint... I would think it would be best if Jesus, Mary, and Joseph were in focus instead of the wise men. Like the composition though, and it is the real reason for Christmas

Going Out
by mandyturner

Comment:
Another recent challenge, wasn't a member yet so didnt' vote on this one, but, I really think it should have placed a higher than it did. My main comment is the frames, have a pretty distinct contrast between them which keeps them from flowing from L to R and makes my eyes bounce around. and I keep trying to line up the eye with the picture on the right like I'm trying to see a complete face. Maybe putting the hair pic in the middle would have helped.

I've been everywhere....
by mandyturner

Comment:
Wanted to comment on one of your pics. Figured maybe one from a recent challenge would be helpful. (BTW your Freestudy IX is very good, couldn't find any real criticism/help to offer)

I gave this a 5 while voting mainly because it had several items, all competing for my attention. It seems a little unbalanced with the stacking of the glasses on LH side. Maybe more of a panoramic side by side treatment would have worked? I think a different color BG would have helped, Darker in my opinion. So, thats my two cents. Thanks for your comments on my hi key post.