Irony
by Turco

Comment:
Critique Club
Composition-Content
Great idea, but I think that you probably lost a lot of people with the meaning of it, one of those times when seeing the photographers comments at the time of voting would have helped! Perhaps a different angle of the sign would have added more interest.
Technical
The true colour of snow has come out well here, nice and clean! Lighting is a little dark, perhaps a different time of day would have been good, or even B/W and then more contrast would have provided a stonger impact.
My Opinion
Great idea and after reading your comments, I can see how this fits the challenge, just needs to be a little more obvious for this site! Good Luck in the next challenge.

Protector
by pitsaman

Comment:
Critique Club
Composition-content
The angle of the shot fits the angle that she is looking, providing space from her eyes into the empty space. Also leaves room for text which is an added benefit for stock. I think that the composition is pretty interesting, I am sure that many people would think that you should have cropped off the pole, but I think composition wise it would have been pretty uninteresting without it.
Technical
Sharpening looks too strong here, resulting in jagged lines. Either that, or in the resizing.
My opinion
I like the composition and choice of B/W, interesting perspective. I think that pictures of pictures don't usually score too highly. Probably would have done much better without the compression/sharpening issues. Intreresting shot!

Waiting for Monsoon...
by snowleopard10101

Comment:
Just had a look at your shot, thought I better mention that you are supposed to take the picture, the week of the challenge! Lucky you to go to India, I would love to go!

Dead of Winter
by byetko

Comment:
Stunning use of DOF, lovely colour and contrast! I love it!

Into the Mist
by karmat

Comment:
I love it! Fantastic composition, beautiful contrast and the fog just tops it off! Good Luck! 10

Eggquisite
by Jean

Comment:
Lovely effect created by the abstract reflections. Great colour and lighting!

Which came first?
by tcherring

Comment:
I love this, its soooo cute! Not sure how you are getting away with the border effect, but it really is lovely!

The egg did it! (making fun of my misfortunes)
by psychephylax

Comment:
Very original shot, the lighting is great!

EGGCLIPSE
by louie c

Comment:
Perhaps a different colour background would have helped the egg stand out more and given more impact. Good Luck!

Hit it long & Straight....
by robcon

Comment:
Unfortunately focus seems a bit soft, nice idea though.