Photoshopped Fire.jpg
by modurn

Comment:
You did a good job removing the other hand and stick as well as the cooler and partial person directly behind the girl. The removal of the other people in the background has left a large darker area that stands out quite a bit.

White Orchid
by w4jzz

Comment:
I like the muted colours and composition. Overall, slightly too much blur for my taste.

Zen-Like
by Chinabun

Comment:
I like the bright greens against the dark background balanced by the rocks at the bottom. I do not like the piece of stem on the left with no leaves and feel it would have been a stronger image without that.

Green Heron
by manishk

Comment:
I think this shot meets the challenge very well. For the challenge, I know you couldn't spot edit the bark, but now you might want to try darkening some of the brighter highlights on the log to put more emphasis on the bird. For sharpening, you might want to try having the threshold at 0 when doing your unsharp mask. I like your overall composition and the colours are great.

matos
by eye has not seen

Comment:
nice colour combinations with the tomatoes, carrots, mustard and peppers. I like the arrangement. I don't like the washed out celery bits.

Check Mate - Carrots Win
by indridistefans

Comment:
I like the idea and the composition. The lighting does not bring out the potential this has, perhaps something softer or at more of an angle would enhance the "chess pieces" more.

It's What's for Dinner
by Cam

Comment:
too rare for me, I like mine more of a medium-well done. :) A fill flash may have helped catch more detail in the animals face and added more interest to the shot.

1/3 Vegetables Invited to Lunch
by Gunnsi

Comment:
I like the bright colours on the dark background. I think it may have been more effective to not have the face carved in the tomato.

I'm getting sleeepy.....
by jad

Comment:
interesting mix of food and condiments. The overall effect is too busy for my taste and the lighting is very flat.

Frosty's rarely seen little brother
by cryingdragon

Comment:
humourous subject choice. The lighting used does little to enhance the photo, perhaps more of a side light might have added more interesting shadows. The background colour may have been better had it been more opposite rather than so similar in tones to your subject.