Forever Autumn
by io

Comment:
7 - Nice scene/landscape. Criticism; just seems it needs a bit of a 'boost', somehow, especially with the reds/yellows, not sure.

No more sailing
by Brin

Comment:
7 - Good 'find' for the Challenge. Not sure on the 'toning', seems the boat gets a little 'lost' in it, not sure.

One Year Later
by elemess

Comment:
7 - Good interpretation.

Untitled
by Tiberius

Comment:
7 - Good interpretation, even though there seems to be a door at the end(?), but I'll assume it is 'permanently locked'.

Dead End
by tfarrell23

Comment:
7 - Like the lines and 'diamond' use.

Xanadu
by Sammie

Comment:
8 - Wow. Very nice contrast of landscapes. Criticism; not much, mostly the sky detracts in my opinion in this shot. Whether you were able to adjust it (contrast etc) not sure, but perhaps an even tighter crop (less sky) would have made this a better shot in my opinion, although I realize you'd lose some 'context'. Like the shadow play on the dunes and mountains, but wonder if just a fraction more 'lightness' overall, possibly showing some more of the green in the mountains may have also made it better. Perhaps even more of the fore 'plain' too, especially if cropping out more sky, not sure, who knows. Good shot.

Tarague Beach
by autohuff

Comment:
4 - Nice colors. Criticism; definitely needs to be 640, preferably width, at least.

In the valley
by alithenake

Comment:
7 - Very good. However I have no idea if the horizon is straight, based on the 'slant' of the houses and the clouds, etc so not sure (apologies if wrong). Criticism; not much, perhaps a bit sharper on the fence post(s), but maybe you would lose the definition in the 'scene'. The shot has the potential for a more dramatic feel in my opinion, but perhaps you were not going for that, but if so, maybe a tweaking of the contrasts, etc, especially bringing out a bit more coloring. Has a nice 'feel' to it as is though. Good perspective.

Stormy Seas at Dawn
by DrAchoo

Comment:
7 - Nice shot and effects. Criticism; the frame may be a touch too 'heavy' for this scene, in my opinion, not sure. Like the contrasting 'scapes.

Autum
by Halim

Comment:
5 - Mostly for the potential. Criticism; firstly, at least the width to be 640, if not the height as well, depending what you were going for/what was 'there'. I like the colors in this, especially the green duckweed/algae/whatever and the contrasting black/slate rock and would like to have seen, perhaps a sharper angle (ground/rock) and more of the rock and river(?) (again dependent) incorporated, as well as the other side of the bank if possible, especially for this Challenge. edit:typo - sorry you did not find my comment helpful

Message edited by author 2005-11-16 00:24:25.