cardinel4-copy1.jpg
by Phillydigishooter

Comment:
Nice capture of the two together. Perhaps a crop variation here to try to gain more balance and show more detail (quality dependent) would make this even better. Apologies in advance if wrong and/or it is natural, but seems a slight purple tint/tinge to this as well.

by Decod

Comment:
Nice reflection, 'lines' and colors. The horizon looks like it needs a nudge rotation up on the left to get it nice and level. The blown/overexposed sky - difficult to control and retain the reflection so well, perhaps someone with more knowledge can offer suggestions on how to minimize that.

Neighbor
by Jutilda

Comment:
Nice shot. Colors are nice. Maybe the cat totally in frame, not sure - as does work well as is.

DSC_0430.jpg
by AChelton

Comment:
Good capture. Like to see more detail though - quality dependent, perhaps a tighter crop may allow for this, not sure. The eagle(?) seems to get a little lost against the background/foliage, so whether a tighter cropping would help that, or perhaps a tweaking of the colors or toning variation, not sure.

Dirty Track
by Kita

Comment:
I gave this a 4. I liked the perspective - not too fond of the choice of subject to 'focus on' - but your call on that. Difficult to adjust the crop and lose the diminishing 'horizon' of the road - but if that top right corner where the grass seems to end could have been cropped out, might have made this better in my opinion. Looks like it (the focal point) needs to be a fraction sharper too.

The Reality of Abstract
by rjpat

Comment:
5 - Like this. Wish it were bigger (640 width in this case), but might be quality issues, so perhaps a selective softening of the background - not sure as that might alter/diminish the 'abstractness'.

Eye of the Machine
by yantski

Comment:
6 - wish it were bigger (640 x 640).

Sky absrtact
by gisli

Comment:
3 - Very nice shot but for this Challenge, if the aurora/sky were the only subject would have made this better (and more apt) in my opinion. Even the reflection on the water incorporated too would have been good but judging by this perspective, near impossible without the 'land'.

Two coaches
by pix-are

Comment:
Gave this a 7. Thought it was a fairly good capture/candid and showed the 'moment' well. Not sure on the selective desaturation and toning, 'works' but .. not sure. Overall a little 'soft' as well, whether that is pp or not, not sure - which again 'works' but.. perhaps a bit sharper/more definition may have helped.

The Ice Breakers
by owen

Comment:
Gave this a 7. Thought it was a good shot - just if a little sharper/more definition (even on the verging silhouette) of the man at fore and the horizon was perfectly level (off by the slightest degree), make this even better in my opinion.