Trixie
by manu

Comment:
7 - Nice shot of Trixie. Minor, but wish the nose was more in focus. A little more space 'around' her head too.

A pet. A friend. A teacher.
by silverfeather

Comment:
6 - Like the concept, just wish a more refined crop, no photographer reflection and sharper on the eye and lashes.

Bogart
by heathen

Comment:
7 - Poor old Bogart. Could be just a visual thing, but this looks like it needs a nudge up on the right. Like the setup and composition just wish Bogart looked happier and dominated the shot/frame more - and possibly also 'at camera'.

I am sick of digital changes; take me to Kodak prints for ever
by fkahhaleh

Comment:
1 - No - doesn't meet Challenge.

Harley Cat
by cuspie

Comment:
6 - Beautiful colored eyes. I know this is 640, but like to have seen it 'bigger', somehow. Like the matching green in the composition but wonder if it dominates a little too much. A little sharper (maybe not so close/reduce blur/who knows) and attention paid to the reflection in the eye, make this better in my opinion. Like the potential. Like the thin slits too.

Waiting for a Treat
by bassbone

Comment:
8 - Nice. Like to have seen the dog's left eye more.

Oshie
by PBear

Comment:
4 - Nice pose of Oshie, but even a crop at the top to eliminate the lattice/fenceline make this better in my opinion. Shame the tail is chopped and the blue blanket is too dominant overall and the black plastic in the background, etc - so just attention paid to thos elements.

To the Left
by ShannonLee

Comment:
3 - Definitely like to have seen this more about the dog.

Joe (the) Boxer
by Prof_Fate

Comment:
5 - Find the background detracting as it does not complement the brindle coat, collar also detracts, in my opinion. Looks like some blur issues on the face/head.

Ears and Tail a Twitching
by Kelli

Comment:
4 - Despite your title, ears minimum still make this better in my opinion. Also looks like the focus is stronger further down so a variation there as well as composition and crop choice (especially to not chop off the paws) make this better in my opinion.