Night Stalker
by WickedB

Comment:
5 - Like the concept, but the pp (which does grow on you a little), just a little too much for this Challenge in my opinion. Also, with the almost 'invisible line' along the body, perhaps the framing/crop varied, make this better in my opinion.

Meadow
by cloudsme

Comment:
7 - Nice capture. Shame about the 'chop'.

These magic eyes...
by krasavitsa_1

Comment:
3 - They do look vivid, but don't think you've captured the full potential here. Additionally, the perspective/angle has caused a bit of distortion in the 'cheeks' and it looks a little odd. Focus seems off as well.

Beach Retriever
by Dorsetgirl

Comment:
7 - Nice persective and capture. Difficult, but just a little sharper around the face/eyes and maybe a nudge rotate up on the left, but could just be the perspective.

Hold that pose there friend !
by cubix

Comment:
4 - Too much effects applied/pp for my liking, otherwise seemingly a nice capture.

Teemu
by GolferDDS

Comment:
7 - Obviously opportune, and a good capture, but 'if only' the eyes and face as sharp as the water and stick, but very difficult. Nice portrait though.

Deadly Stare
by Ubersteiny

Comment:
6 - Nice clarity and detail. Perhaps the claws in focus too, but your call, obviously. Background works, but wonder about a contrasting color, but again, your call. Minor, but looks like a little sensor dust just above the right nostril. Also like to have seen a name in the title to 'personalize' this for this Challenge.

Fall Feline
by timfythetoo

Comment:
9 - Very nice. Very nice scene and colors. Just wonder about with the space either side of the cat whether a fraction more above the head would have visually balanced this out even better, but then the cat would be smaller, so who knows. Otherwise, maybe just a little tighter either side. Again, white framing works well, but at this size, I'd just like to have seen the cat bigger. Difficult, but more detail discernible in the cat too.

Got Stick?
by Cantique

Comment:
7 - Nice capture, including of a 'dog's life'. Difficult, but even sharper on the eyes, make this better in my opinion. Minor, but the blue something between the dog's head and forearm detracts slightly, but obviously opportune.

I wish it would snow
by Timy

Comment:
6 - Nice concept. Difficult to get this visually balanced, perhaps offsetting it more and a tighter crop on the left, may have given this an edge. Also like to have seen the 'real cat' sharper, more 'pop'. Not sure on the heavy frame, including color choice, but your call, obviously.