Squeak0198Web.jpg
by Ristyz

Comment:
'5', maybe 6, from me, hypothetically. This doesn't compare to your entry in my opinion, which is a very nice image. Was surprised to see where it placed.

Tabby
by yanko

Comment:
Wow. '9' likely, hypothetically. Eyes look more 'natural' in this, in my opinion.

percy1.jpg
by cryingdragon

Comment:
'5' hypothetically from me.

gpig.jpg
by faidoi

Comment:
'7' likely from me. Nice outdoor portrait.

Corner Kitty
by jenesis

Comment:
Nice image. This and your others don't compare with your very good entry though, in my opinion.

Braving the weathers
by Mephisto

Comment:

Originally posted by Mephisto: ..@macrothing: this horse is (unfortunately) not mine, so i don't know its name, i wonder if it even has one...i'll ask it next time i see it

You do that or.. just make one up next time. Thanks for the response to my comment.

not entering.jpg
by mk

Comment:
'5' likely, maybe 6 - depends where you cropped it to get it 640 ":)". Hope you 'understood' the comment on your real entry. This has a much better 'feel' to it, in my opinion...

Gracie - Chinchilla
by rjkstesch

Comment:
'7' - hypothetically from me. Nice detail and nice 'elements'.

V.
by muur88

Comment:
9 - Oh, this is very nice. Really like the simplicity and color choices, including background patterns. The horizontal framing works well, as would a vertical I imagine. Not sure on the black frame, but fairly minor. Could be just a visual thing but the left 'space' seems a fraction bigger / wider than the right. Looks like resizing issues, but just a little more detail / clarity in the eyes.. but likely there full size. Sure this looks good bigger. Seems some shadowing/something going on above V.'s crown/forehead, not sure. Up to 9 from 8. Really like the pose/capture.

18 years
by yanko

Comment:
8 - Really like this, especially the symmetry and colors, but the overall 'feel' to it seems a little over processed to me (especially around the eyes), but might just be a matter of personal taste. Just like to have seen more detail and texture, in the eyes, fur, etc - looks slightly unnatural. A fraction wider likely have worked well too, but fairly minor, works well as is. As for the age... with clarity in the eyes like that, one lucky cat. Up to 8 from 7.