Petals
by Drake

Comment:
5 - Think I understand what you were going for, but don't think it has reached full potential - perhaps a little more depth and contrast, along with a more refined crop/composition.

Seagull on beach
by SoulJance

Comment:
5 - I like the potential, but composition seems lacking, along with borderline definition (more or less).

Modern Fauve: We Can Evolve
by PennyStreet

Comment:
5 - Many would find this appealing, but it is not my thing.

Soundstage Left
by franktheyank

Comment:
5 - Not doing much for me with this crop, including the water bottle bottom left.

u n t i t l e d
by Bear_Music

Comment:
6 - I like the shades, the processing and the symmetry, but it feels a little awkward, albeit subtly - mainly the glimpse of trees in the rear and the top right corner of the field. Up to 6 from 5 though.

Two Calla Leafs
by Nadine_Vb

Comment:
5 - Good potential, but I find the composition isn't enhancing/showcasing them in an artistic way enough. The tones are also a little dull.

Storm
by mqnaufal

Comment:
5 - Flowers in a vase with movement (I know I shouldn't necessarily be trying to guess what it is), either through camera movement or manually moving the vase/objects ... I like the composition, I like the shapes/patterns/lines, I like the gradients and shadings.. but I'm just not getting much from the b&w with this - not sure why. Also, maybe my eyes want it mirrored (as in flipped), I'm not sure. I also wish the top of the 'reeds' were not chopped.

Rural Poetry
by Ammie

Comment:
5 - I think I understand the concept, but there is nothing 'extra-ordinary' for me about the image, including the processing, etc - however (and I realize this may well be the case), if that is your intent, because 'rural poetry' in an everyday scene such as this, is what you deem 'fine art' - then that's your call, of course. For me, without the car and maybe a little less sky... but another image.

The Woman in the Tunnel
by ZellerStudio

Comment:
5 - Yes I see, but I'm distracted too much by other elements, including the 'uncomfortable' horizontal framing - but just my perception.

nightlife 47
by Spork99

Comment:
5 - Like the effect and the potential with it, but the scene is too 'ordinary' for me and doesn't add anything.