Greg Bennett Royale RL1 - $259.00
by arron_christensen

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Color: 2/2
Composition: 2/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 2/2

Excellent work here. It's nice to finally see a photo that took more thought than simply grabbing a camera quickly and shooting something as it passes by, and trying to pass it off as a product shot. The placement of the guitar is perfect, with just enough room on all sides to really make it stand out, but not look crowded in the frame. The lighting is spot on, and the guitar is perfectly sharp. I really like the light trailing off on the guitar strings. Excellent photograph.

Greek vase
by hajeka

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 1/2
Contrast/Color: 2/2
Composition: 1/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 1/2

I think the inclusion of the entire vase would have improved the composition for the challenge, advertising the entire product, not just a piece of it. The photo is tack sharp, with just enough DOF. The isolation of the subject from the background with the plain white always works well for product shots. Nice work.

Boeing E-6A (Crew not included)
by Blackbox

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 0/2
Contrast/Color: 1/2
Composition: 0/2
Photo Quality: 1/2
My Subjective Affinity: 0/2

The first thing I notice is that the photo looks like a snapshot taken with a good zoom. The plane should not be dead center on the vertical axis of the photo. The white sky doesn't help either. The contrast on the plane is too high, leaving the underbody and wheels completely underexposed.

the Absolut mix
by DiSc

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Color: 0/2
Composition: 1/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 1/2

The white balance looks really off in this photo. Also, everything seems underexposed, except for the second bottle, which appears completely blown out on my monitor. There are also several hot spots on the bottles and lids that should have been removed. I also think the inclusion of the entire first bottle could have improved the overall composition of the photograph.

The Illusion of Need
by tate

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Color: 2/2
Composition: 2/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 1/2

I don't exactly get the idea here, but the photo is well executed. Nice work.

TREK 7100........$395
by aimeethetoo

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Color: 1/2
Composition: 2/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 2/2

Excellent idea. The lighting is a bit harsh, leaving a bit to be desired, especially with the tires and seat. Aside from the lighting problem, everything else looks great.

best frickin allen wrench ever
by posthumous

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 1/2
Contrast/Color: 1/2
Composition: 0/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 0/2

Very plain photograph that lacks the necessary interest to make this a successful product photograph.

The Cupcake Lady Catalog
by quiet_observation

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 1/2
Contrast/Color: 0/2
Composition: 1/2
Photo Quality: 1/2
My Subjective Affinity: 0/2

Very contrasty photograph. Detail is somewhat lacking. The colors seem a bit off. And the photo lacks the interest necessary to pull off a shot like this.

Tanning Oil
by nutzito

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Color: 2/2
Composition: 2/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 2/2

Definitely the best of the bunch. Excellent idea! I don't think it could get any better than this. The HT bottle is perfectly exposed, as well as the background. And the limited DOF works perfect for your idea.

Xtreme Heavy Duty Armor...for Men and their Horses
by hahn23

Comment:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 0/2
Contrast/Color: 2/2
Composition: 2/2
Photo Quality: 2/2
My Subjective Affinity: 1/2

Although I don't feel this would work good as a "product shot", the rest of the qualities of the photo are excellent. Good use of limited DOF. Excellent color and sharpness. If only the ropes weren't in there. And great stop action also.