Bouquet
by SJCarter

Comment:
I like the way you have opted for a different kind of Triptych, BUT, the subject, whilst nice, isnt quite exciting enough to make me go WOW.. still, 7 from me. well done.

Hells Kitchen
by MAK

Comment:
I knew this was MAKS purely from the style & the model (his son). The worrying thing was I wanted to give it a ten, as liking his style, have marked him high in the past, this time though I dropped it a couple of marks so as not to get into trouble with `friend` voting. Its sad that its come to this.

Even if his son wasnt in the shot, I would of known it was hish, purely because whenever a new filter or style is discussed in the forums, MAK is generally one of the first to put it into practice in a challenge environment, and I take my hat off to that, howevr, and this is constructive critism, he also has a tendancy to overuse a new effect until the `next big thing` is discussed, just look at his tonempaping entries!! (however this could of been his undoing as others know his style and due to recent evernts, felt the need to `punish` him.. who knows).

Nice shot mate. At least it hit top 5, any lower would of been a travesty.

Message edited by author 2007-04-30 11:06:38.

simple
by krnodil

Comment:
love it.. top 10 at least. 8

My table setter, cook, dishwasher, and stove
by ibkc

Comment:
LOL, was it intentional just to have the "H" and "O" showing..

or is that just my sick & twisted way of thinking.

Hells Kitchen
by MAK

Comment:
lol, I recognise this model and style.. Wont be seeing him for a few months I bet! great shot, pity the eye nearest the camera has the pupil obscured by flying food. overall good shot. 8

Apple Desaturator
by jgrieco

Comment:
great idea. 7

FORKS & KNIFES & SPOONS
by TJinGuy

Comment:
too small, blurry, white balance way off, boring subject. 1

On Stand-By
by Jas

Comment:
wow, I love this shot. Simplsitic yet contemporary.. great idea. gotta be a 9

Stir Fry
by pawdrix

Comment:
This would look good in a cookbook. 6

Memorable bowl
by dcb300

Comment:
OK, I dont want to be too negative, but this is a still life, not a moving subject, yet still you managed to cut off the left side of the bowl a fraction, and the spoon/fork in the bowl. The lighting is very flat as well.. next time, try getting an interesting angle on the shot. a face on shot of a bowl is never going to impress anyone.. are you 100% happy with this shot? no, didnt think so. keep trying though.