Roundness of Toilet Paper
by MochaNova1987

Comment:
Needs to be in focus.

Red beauty
by Krisby

Comment:
This has a lot of potential, but I think your lighting is a little harsh. Did you only use a flash. Also, IMHO, the perspective could be improved. I'd like to see you shooting the lamp shade straight on, so we just get the shape, and don't see the gathered material at the top. I'd also straighten the fringe at the bottom.

Venus de Shell...oh
by Joy Moore

Comment:
Needs to be sharper.

Columns
by banmorn

Comment:
I can't make up my mind if this is a shape picture, a texture picture, or a pattern picture. It's got it all!

Arch-shaped Blooms
by davidus428

Comment:
I really like the shallow DOF on this one, but IMHO it's a little too shallow. That spiral curve at the tip of the bloom is really interesting, and it goes all fuzzy.

Time a-Round the World
by PhantomEWO

Comment:
This is a really interesting picture, but to my eye the shapes of the watches aren't the most interesting aspect of the picture. The map is very interesting, too, and my eye goes more to the faces of the watches, not their shapes. It's a good picture, but IMHO, not for a shapes challenge.

my favorite shape
by jossy

Comment:
This picture needs to be larger. From what I can see, the color and texture are more important than the shape.

caged
by arsenal

Comment:
You wuz robbed.

route 46
by talonrs

Comment:
Good lighting and great tones. IMHO I'd get rid of the heavy black border.

Creek Bridge BW
by hutch699

Comment:
I think this picture has potential, but right now, it's gray, not black and white. To my eye, you have to bump up the contrast and get some real blacks and real whites in there. Good luck.