The line is dead
by ajschel

Comment:
cool phone! love the texture in the wall. Love the colors of the phone. Composition/crop good. POV good. 7 from me - good luck in the challenge!

The Age of Steam
by p2jvr

Comment:
like this. probably could crop just a little off the bottom. DOV, POV good. 6 - good luck in the challenge!

Abandoned
by jbsmithana

Comment:
Hey, the SS minnow! Works in B&W. I might have cropped out the top - alot going on that is unneccesary to the image - don't think cutting off the pole or whatever it is would be noticed that much. Good entry for the challenge. Good luck!

No longer watertight
by gingerninja

Comment:
like the image as is but I also wish there was a little more space around it to give me a sense of place. Excellent job keeping the detail in conversion to black and white. Love the tones. 8 from me - good luck in the challenge!

That eBay Photo
by Konador

Comment:
completely underrated image. Great composition, great clarity and depth, excellent tones. And, the teapot is SO shiny you can see your reflection. ;) Loved it - sorry it didn't do better. Didn't deserve the low scores it got.

BTW - love your profile image!

Message edited by author 2005-06-29 21:30:04.

Lost Shoe
by james_so

Comment:
LMAO. Thank you - with all the seriousness here lately we needed one of these. 10 for your sense of humor. The pic is okay too. Stopped by to laugh again. Like the composition by the way.

Reel Mower
by JeremyFleury

Comment:
Don't think I like selective desat here. Personal thing. I think a little crop on the right may help. Right now this image feels left heavy. Great take on the challenge!

Tray
by mamcg

Comment:
Yes it is. But what is that gross stuff on it? :) Like the colors and the contrast. Composition good. You will hear, "But I use trays at McDonald's everyday!" Can't please everyone - and they eat at McDonalds! 6 from me - good luck in the challenge!

Hello?
by Patrol

Comment:
With the angle like this I wish you had included a little more wall to the left. Tones and textures good. 6 - good luck in the challenge!

'Paraffin Lightbulb'
by Simonkasprzak

Comment:
this image has a lot of potential. I think you need a large piece of paper for the background - the horizontal line is conspicuous. I think, with larger paper, you could have gotten just a little further away to show us the whole object. DOF is good. Point of view is okay but straight on tends be static. Good luck in the challenge!