ready or not
by bohemka

Comment:
This is a great photo. I love the balance (though it's not perfectly level), and the processing is perfect. It's a 9 from me. Well done.

in search of four
by bspurgeon

Comment:
This is a Top 10 image. Up there with a handful of others that I gave a 9 to. Brilliant balance. Will surely do well with voters and judges.

Lament
by Paul

Comment:
This is by far the best image in the challenge... sure thing to win the blue with the judges, and probably with the voters. Well done on a great entry! A 10 from me.

Got Milk
by salmiakki

Comment:
This is my favourite image in the challenge and well deserving of the 10 I gave it... would have been an 11 if I could have given it. Congratulations on the yellow.

Jezza's backyard
by nick_hinch

Comment:
This is a wonderful image... and well deserving of the Posthumous accolades... very under appreciated.

Concentration
by rooum

Comment:
Now I feel silly... ME having given YOU tips on how to improve a photo. Well done on a great photo.

The Yarra
by hotpasta

Comment:
Oh how I miss thee... nice position. Beautifully processed.

Concentration
by rooum

Comment:
This would have been a GREAT image had you
(a) not lost the toes of the girl in the iddle
(b) processed it in B&W
(c) gotten a little lower to take the shot.
This scene had enormous potential, and you've shown that you have the eye for great situation portraits, or street photography, but there just a few elements that will hurt this image with the general voting public... I do expect you'll probably get some better marks from some quarters of the DPC community though.
So... what am I going to give it... initially, I was thinking a 5 or 6... but looking at it from a different perspective, had you done all those things above, I reckon I'd be giving it a 10, so, I'm thinking somewhere between... so, you're getting an 8 from me.

Guns N Roses: Chinese Democracy
by LandzEnca

Comment:
This would be a great album cover, and superbly linked to a great album.

sit down young stranger, gordon lightfoot
by bspurgeon

Comment:
This is simply stunning for it's minimalism and would work PERFECTLY as an album cover... brilliant job with this. I'm bumping this up to a 9.