The Horse
by birgir

Comment:
Must be a *tiny* magazine... :) Please try to provide a bigger shot -- it's awfully hard to make a good judgement on such a small image...

Home and Design
by sher

Comment:
Beautifully done! Not much more I can offer than that! Looks like there's a teeny bit of excessive grain here, but it's a wonderful scene. - 9

Cigar Aficionado
by bgmorris

Comment:
I could be wrong, considering I'm not a smoker... but doesn't this basically depict cigar smoking as a bad thing? I would think that a magazine that is promoting cigars wouldn't want to show ugly ashes, along with a cigar being snuffed out.

National Geographic
by InnaN

Comment:
It really does look like an issue of National Geographic! Seems like there's just a teeny bit too much headroom here, but it's a great shot.

But you can stay and play a while...
by qachyk

Comment:
Well, the colors of the "contraption" are interesting and provide for some interesting contrasts... but the overall image needs a little help, I'm afraid. The overall image is blurry with no particular area being in full focus. The bar at the bottom and the window on the right seem to act as distractions. And I'm honestly not sure how the sign fits in with the rest of the shot.

My keyboard
by Crafty Sue

Comment:
In all honesty, it just doesn't look like much thought was put into this. Sorry to sound harsh... but it's "just a picture of a keyboard." The counterclockwise tilt feels uncomfortable, and the apparent use of flash created over-lit spots in the center of the shot. Again, I hate being harsh in comments, but if I score something low, I generally try to provide an explanation as to why... - 2

Turf War
by GeneralE

Comment:
May have been stronger if the stapler and staple remover were isolated against a plain backdrop. There seem to be too many other elements to conflict with the subjects here.

Bug's Office
by pitsaman

Comment:
Somehow I knew someone would manage to squeeze a flower shot in here somewhere...

Stress management
by tommy_t

Comment:
Neat items and technique with the reflection. The crop seems just a tad bit too tight, though.

Complaint Department
by draney4

Comment:
I'm afraid this just doesn't work for me in general... sorry... The shot is just too cluttered (granted, intentionally), and the reverse effect just isn't flattering. Sorry to be rather harsh on this one...