Entangled
by MaxheadrooM

Comment:
Just dosen't do it for me as far as composition. Lighting is cool though.

Its and Bits
by Talarria

Comment:
A little on the dark side IMHO. Also compositionally this doesn't say Obsolete to me it looks more like a pile of garbage.

Shipwreck (infrared)
by marbo

Comment:
Bumping you up from a 4 to a 5. It's very nice, but the infrared has been overdone in the last few challenges IMHO.

worn out
by crank2o

Comment:
Gave you 4 for the following reasons. 1. White Balance is off, there is hardly any true white in this pic. 2. It's composition didn't do anything for me. I appreciate the joke and am glad you diidn't use brown syrup like the last leaky condom pic I saw.

Outhouse
by charliebaker

Comment:
Needs a little more contrast, highlights are a tad bit blown on the rim. Compositionally this pic didn't WOW me. 5.

Hey , the bus is leaving
by soheil

Comment:
I didn't vote this one very high because of the depth of field. The foreground being that out of focus and the background being so sharp yet being blocked by the front just doesn't work for me, IMHO. Good title though.

Outlived but valued
by kaedemoon267

Comment:
Voted this 3 on the firstgo, moving it up to a 5 this one. The size really bothers me, you can post up to 640 pixels and you lose a lot of detail when you post his small. Technically it's an ok picture, maybe a little blown out on the right upper side. Compositionally I would have moved in closer and left out some of the plants. Of course this just my opinon.

Old Rope
by Apocalypse

Comment:
Voted this a 3 on my first pass, moving it up to 5 on this one. In future challenges you may want to consider a larger picture (640 pixels is allowed). Voters here, including myself, tend to score low for smaller pics. That said, overall not a bad pic technically, just dosen't pop for me compositionally.

Coal Car
by Brigid

Comment:
I voted this a 4 for the following reasons. 1. Picture is very small, so very little detail can be seen. 2. It's kind of a snap shot, the framing is direct on. (Possibly a lower angle and a little closer would have made it pop more for me) 3. It doesn't have lot of contrast. IMHO

Sight
by bcoble

Comment:
Interesting effect, sorry your cat is blind. I had a 20 yr. old cat simalar to this one. I scored you low because of the harsh light, (I'm guessing direct flash), really blows out the fur on the bridge of the nose and the subject doesn't pop for me.