Sunset on the horizon
by xertion

Comment:
I'm not too fond of the powerlines, but the sunset is very pretty. I like the colors, and this silhouettes are good. Focus looks good. Angle and framing/cropping are alright as well. The powerlines look like they are tilting. Could just be an illusion or something, but I think that's why they bother me a bit. Nice view. Good luck in the challenge.

THE BARN IN GLENWILLOW
by STEINR

Comment:
Kind of a dreary day, but I like the colors. The darkness works for me. Focus and clarity are great, and the angle and framing/cropping are good as well. I like how you have included the road in the pic, and the fence also. Nice shot. Good luck in the challenge.

Abandoned to the Cold Prairie
by jimmsp

Comment:
Would a very slight left rotation mess up the angle of the building? If not, I'd like to see the horizon line leveled off a bit. There is a horizontal line in the field, so it makes the tilt look worse than it really is, so I don't really think it's a big deal. I love the use of black and white here. Levels are nice. Focus and clarity are also great. Good luck in the challenge.

at sunrise
by BeeGee

Comment:
Not really quite sure what to say here. The buildings are straight, but the 'horizon' line is falling off the left side of the photo. Is there a hill out there or something? If you straightened up the horizon, your buildings would be tilting, so while I'm not really fond of the tilted horizon (or the LOOK like the horizon is tilted) I really can't say to rotate to the right, cause then the buildings would be off. The sunset is really pretty, and the silhouettes are nice as well. Good luck in the challenge.

McAlpine
by jboling

Comment:
I know that the unlevel look is due to the curve of the shore line, but I think that a right rotation would still help this a bit. It would level the tree line in the back, making it look more 'uniform', if there is such a thing. The color is very nice. I like how the sky is just a bit lighter than the reflection of the sky. Focus and clarity are good. The view would be much prettier in summer or fall, but some silly people chose this challenge in winter. lol. Good luck in the challenge.

Place of stillness
by vjoz

Comment:
Did you chose black and white cause the sky was white and blank? I'm seeing white sky in a lot of shots this week. must be the weather. Anyway, I like the choice for black and white, and I think that is makes the white sky not so bad. It's a lovely mountain. Looks like a pyrimid. I like the angle and framing/cropping you chose as well. Having the sign in the front, although I have no idea what it says, is very nice. GOod shot. Good luck in the challenge.

Seasons
by aurora

Comment:
Wow. That is really really amazing. Beautiful landscape. I love everything about this really. Angle and framing/cropping, focus and clarity, lighting. Everything. It's wonderfully divided. The sky is beautiful too. Great color. Nothing I would like to see differently. Great shot. Good luck in the challenge. 10

Solitude
by stephan

Comment:
Nice way of framing the left of the photo with the tree. The angle and framing/cropping are great in my opinion. The barn looks very lonely, and so it's titled well. Focus and clarity are good. I like the black and white. Does it have a slight color tint? or are my eyes playing tricks on me. The lighting conditions look like they were good. no distracting hot spots or shadows. nice landscape. Good luck in the challenge.

Rollin' Away
by inspzil

Comment:
Well, I thought I'd put my 2 cents in since I saw this in the least commented section. I can't stand to see a neglected photo. I see you got absolutely NO help on this. Here is what I see...
I see that there used to be 4 balls in the shot. The 3 sitting there, and the one rolling away. The reflection is nice. The shot seems grainy, but it COULD just be the texture of the balls. I like the effect of the ball rolling away and the angle and framing/cropping are good. I like how the balls are lined up at a slight diagonal, and not straight across the photo. Lighting is good for this shot, as there really is no need for anything other than the balls. Background is perfect. the white balls stand out very nicely on the black background. It's simply, but it's still a good shot. Can't figure why this didn't get any comments.
~Heather~

Five Minutes From Midtown.
by catpixel

Comment:
That is such a beautiful bridge that I wish we could see more of it. Understand why you didn't though. Suposed to be landscape, not bridge. So that was a good choice. I'm drawn to the red coat(?). Seems like my brain wants to know exactly what it is. Suspect it's a person, but want to know for sure, you know? I think the colors are good. As good as they can be in winter anyway. Focus seems good, and the angle and framing/cropping is ok. Good luck in the challenge.