Sawtooth Peaks
by BaldurT

Comment:
I like the scene but it's a bit flat; no true blacks or true whites.

Circles of water
by Neat

Comment:
I thought this was an Awesome shot for this challenge. Love the color, the subject matter, and the composition. In retrospect I should have scored this higher. As it was I gave it an 8 and was tied for my Top Pick. Well seen, and as always, well captured.

echoes of a world
by krnodil

Comment:
I really enjoyed this image. The B&W choice was perfect. Very pleasing image. Well done. Tied for my Top Pick (had two that I scored an 8).

Cheese
by MargaretNet

Comment:
Wow.

Cheese
by MargaretNet

Comment:
I really want to like this (I do actually) but the face having some motion blur is a bummer. Almost a top choice.

grandma napping without her dentures
by skewsme

Comment:
I thought this was awesome! Nice find. Was my Top Pick for this challenge. Surprised it didn't make the front page.

Aftermath
by grahamgator

Comment:
In my Top 3. Nicely seen and well captured. I thought that you took a challenging scene and really found an interesting perspective on it. The processing approach works well too.

Aftermath
by mefnj

Comment:
My top pick. Loved the comp and the processing. The 'Aftermath' here is very evident and this is truly an artistic representation of the subject / topic. Well done. Just sorry to see it didn't make the Top 3.

Light and Shade
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
This was in my Top 3 - gave it an 8. The shadows with the B&W presentation sold it for me. Just enough left out of the frame to keep it edgy. Well done.

Statue
by DistantColours

Comment:
FWIW - Had this tied for my top pick (I gave out two 9's). I really this abstract image, and have tilted my head both ways to see if it played any better with a different perspective - nope, it plays just fine this way! Great detail and just enough side light. Only nit that could have held it back some is it gets a bit softer near the bottom edge. A square crop perhaps to lose that? Bah. Just speculating. It is what it is, and I liked it. Well done.