Above the clouds
by MargaretNet

Comment:
What's the subject - the mountain peaks? If yes, they're a substantial part of the scene. ??? Doesn't seem like Minimalism to me. Sorry.

Rainy days and Mondays
by Neat

Comment:

Originally posted by IreneM: Great image, love all the umbrellas. However, that song's been driving me crazy all morning... Aaargh!... ;-))

Ha! I missed the song connection. I loved listening to the Carpenters back in the day. Was a sad day when Karen left us early. Congrats on the top level finish on your entry.

Main Street
by Gringo

Comment:
Wow! 7 years since your last entry! Good to see you back in the mix. :-)

Take the high road
by Dennisheckman

Comment:
Oh, I definitely gave it some consideration (regardless of what score I gave this). Hurts to hear the truth of what someone has to say about your entry? Not really getting the correlation between these misstatements in your photographer comments. ???

"My misjudgment led to a mediocre voting result. I normally tick the comments as helpful no matter what, but not this time."

I don't really care if my comments are marked helpful or not. I make them most of the time on a spur of the moment whim. I do like to go back after a challenge is over and see if my comments lined up with observations made by others. â€Â¦ and also to read the Photographers comments when available.

Best of luck to you. FWIW - I do like your image as a standalone; just not quite what I expected to see in this challenge. :-)

Walk on a grey day
by hajeka

Comment:
I like this, especially from the point of meeting the challenge of a Minimalistic subject. I'm on the fence about the pure grey of the image. It's very flat tonally. Good luck.

Winter Sun
by danielstarrason

Comment:
This is a fun take on the challenge. Not sure if we're being fooled with an optical illusion trick - if so, well done. If not I'm giving you (voting) the benefit of the doubt for an interesting capture. :-)

All is Calm
by vawendy

Comment:
So awesome having a black cat!!! This is fun interpretation of the challenge theme. Good luck!

Road Sign
by Mona

Comment:
Well this is fun. :-)

by Lydia

Comment:
I keep sliding off!

The Abyss
by roz

Comment:
Tough to pull back and leave the subject small when you have such an interesting subject to present. IMO it's filling quite a bit of space for a Minimalism approach. ???