Jack The Ribbler
by siggithor

Comment:
Really interesting shot… I like the idea, but I don't like the jacketed figure. I think the shot would have stood really well without it – the overall texture, the rain and the sky reflection would have worked really well on their own; but that figure is a blot on the shot that draws the eye away from the wonderful patterns created by the rain drops. Sorry to be so negative, and good luck… (4)

Agawa Canyon
by rapsiii3

Comment:
The angle totally took me by surprise. People will either love it, or they'll hate it. Personally, I love the fractal like pattern you have framed here; this is just surreal… I keep looking and I keep thinking, yup this is great… (10)

Oakleys and Margaritas
by spiderman

Comment:
Just classic. Love the idea, and I love the way you've done it. Making it look easy is the mark of a good photographer and you have made a hard shot look easy… This shot is magic (10) Great capture…

Saganaski Sunrise
by rbattles

Comment:
Awesome shot (10)

Brothers Remembered
by KarenB

Comment:
Sad image; but the shot works really well. The colours and lines, DOF and sharpness all work really well together with the exception of the much darker lower portion of the shot; this adds a little to much subliminal conflict for my liking; I'd have cropped that section personally. Apart from that, the shot is well balanced and interesting. (7)

Transparent
by nds

Comment:
Superb… This shot has a dramatic, futuristic but cold feel. The lines in shot work to compliment the atmosphere really well… Great shooting… (10)

Tranquility
by neries

Comment:
I think it's a great shot, but perhaps the composition shouldn't have been quite so central. I think there's something not right here, but I'm not sure what, and that's the only explanation I can come up with that makes any sense. (5)

Leaded Glass
by DigiPique

Comment:
If only you could get rid of the flowers in the bottom left hand corner… The eye is immediately drawn away from the subject because of the heavily contrasting colours down there. This creates a huge conflict within the image, mainly because of the symmetrical uniformity within the rest of the shot… If I mentally crop them out, the shot becomes significantly better, probably by about four points on my personal scale. Sorry to be so negative… (5)

Now you see me....
by io

Comment:
Inventive, great use of neutral colour, superb composition; this is a terrific shot. The real winner for me is the way that you've handled the focus on the switch and reflection – it works so well because of it's simplicity – so often, less is best… (10) Great shooting…

Analog to Digital
by magnetic9999

Comment:
Wonderful shot. The composition works really well; I'm not sure if this counts, but the guitar stand spoils it a bit. But, it is part of the studio, so I'd guess that it doesn't. Because I'm a musician myself with a similar set of equipment, I have spent a little more time on this one – I've got a similar spec guitar I think, mine's an Ibanez Jem 77 Floral – because it interests me personally. Great shot (9)