Lens to Lens
by Heavy

Comment:
Intersting idea, but the background should be red all the way down. There's some kind of scratch between the cams in the background. Or I'm just seeing things (time to go to bed ;)
Perhaps a less direct perspective would have been nice. Like, taking a shot over the shoulder of someone photographing the old camera...if you understand what I mean, it's hard to explain what I have in mind. 5.

Toys
by shuchi

Comment:
So, which one's new and which one's old? I know you're referring to the three men as old, but the difference isn't clear enough. Also, you cropped off the dog's right foot. Your lighting is good thouh. The shadows are just right. 4.

Solid Power versus Transparent Power
by PeterC

Comment:
Reminds me of my outtake. Nice shot, great lighting (dawn?) in the upper half, a bit too flat in the lower half. Nice colours and tones. 7.

Changing pastimes
by jonpink

Comment:
Very neat. Good lighting. I like the idea, too. Sad but true... 8.

In Time
by tolovemoon

Comment:
You've got some bad JPEG artifacts in there. Set the camera to take pictures at a hivher quality or set a lower compression rate when saving it after editing.
I can't see a distinguishable difference between the elements that would show me what is old and what is new. The plant is cut off at the top, and the front wheel is in the shadow (it should be lit). 4.

Mr.Innocent
by CoopersCowgirl

Comment:
This doesn't fit the challenge for me. Also, it's not sharp enough, the head is cut off both on top and at the bottom. 3.

Mine.. and Mom's...Generations
by sfarrell23

Comment:
The negative space doesn't add to the imaege IMO. Rings and diamonds are hard to photograph. They need more detail and nicer reflections. 5.

Juxtaposition
by neehai

Comment:
I'm sorry but I see only new things. Nothing old. Are you referring to the bench in the lower right? Doesn't look that old... Nice panorama, nonetheless. Interesting bridge. 5.

Modern Advantage
by bruski

Comment:
Great composition and lighting. Good choice of subject. Where did you get those? I also like the crop. 10.

1927 vs 2003
by kenbo

Comment:
Cool book. I hope there's something inside :). Good idea, neat and sharp. There should be less dust on the black surface. 7.