You Name It........
by clickodak

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

A well executed image that meets the challenge.

A fun challenge that gives you complete free reign without even having to think of a title. Wouldn̢۪t it be nice if all challenges generated this amount of response from the viewers! Haven't you generated a lot of responses and despite that your own suggestion wasn't used.

I very much like the fact that you probably had to use +EC to get that snow looking the way it should do – white! Well done. Too often the whites of snow come out a horrible murky grey through too little thought and effort. I like the focal point of the foreground stump of a tree, I rather wish the orange sign wasn't there in such lovely natural surroundings. I like the way the snow trails lead us into the forest.

So, I reckon you want a tile from me? What about
eeny, meeny, miny, moâ€Â¦
Sid

"You Name It"
by Drake

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

A reasonable image that meets the challenge.

What a fun challenge this was, a very relaxed, easy to fulfil theme. So, thank you for introducing me to this process, something I have never seen before, does one tree really fill all those buckets?

In terms of the image itself your chosen wide open aperture has nicely softened background detail down so that we can concentrate on the tree itself. I find the lighting harsh and very contrasty I think it would have been better for you to have shot it in better light. The crop is a little inaccurate, with part of another bucket appearing right on the edge of the frame, and therefore distracting. Also your position includes a soft focus background shape clinging to the bucket, it would have been better to hide this behind the bucket.

You've received lots of novel suggestions for a title so in keeping with the rest of your commenters I really cannot let the side down can I, how about;
'birds air raid shelters'.
Well done, Sid

BIG FISH
by Ja-9

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

A good interpretation that meets the challenge fully.

A clever and different way of fulfilling the challenge, your subject was obviously very co-operative in holding his breath and a static position while the surface returned to calmness so full marks to him. His expression borders on serenity, very womblike, but instead the cramping of his lips introduces an element of tension too.

Unlike your commenter, I find the white ripples very distracting and detrimental to the overall effect. I presume these are the result of the use of flash? It would have been good to see the result without flash. I like the dark background which for me enhances the result.

A respectable score and appreciative comments so all in all a good result, well done, Sid

A Little Crooked with Your Straight?
by Ja-9

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

An interesting image that may have challenged voters interpretation in respect of the challenge brief.

Although I like your interpretation, 'Skewed horizons, twisted perspectives' was the essence of the challenge, in that respect your image does not meet the challenge. However, I can see that you have chosen to make the viewers work a little harder than the immediately obvious with your juxtaposition of the prominent foreground tree that got last along the way in its straight growth to the sky as shown by all the rest of the trees. Personally, I like images that get the grey matter working.

I am assuming your overexposure was deliberate? It gives the image a sort of ephemeral feel with the resultant loss of detail concentrating the mind more on the straight trunks themselves so in that respect it works. Being a minimal editing challenge you weren't able to use perspective control which would have been good to straighten all the trunks perfectly and then tilt them. Given those restrictions I think I would have deliberately tilted in camera to more clearly fulfil the challenge brief and thereby, hopefully, attract a better score, but it was still respectably received.

Well done for your interesting take on the subject, Sid

Escher's City
by romil

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

Congratulations on your high placing for this excellent image that fits the challenge very well.

A fascinating image with so much detail to get absorbed in. A great title that immediately translates the image into the sort of work you associate with Escher, it works very well.

Technically it is very well executed with good DOF and detail throughout. I suppose it could be argued that the ISO is too high given your fast shutter speed, in fact I think with all the people it would have been a great opportunity to use a deliberately slow shutter speed to blur the motion of moving people which would have added another dimension to it.

I like your conversion to mono with a nice range of tones throughout, it is far more preferable to the colour version, it grabs our attention much more effectively. Your exposure is very well handled with good detail throughout.

An excellent entry thoroughly deserving of its high score, well done, Sid

On Many Levels
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

An excellent entry fully deserving of the appreciative score and comments that meets the challenge very well.

I'm sorry the image caused you so much hassle but it was well worth all the effort. It's difficult to conceive of a more suitable entry especially at the angle you have chosen too. It makes for fascinating viewing with so much detail to absorb.

Technically it has been very well executed with good DOF and sharpness throughout. What would have been a horrible bland and boring sky is working to your advantage in its uniformity.

The only thing that has been confusing me is the distant horizon through the bridge supports, I assumed it was the ocean but there appears to be a significant dip which looked most odd but when I look at the same horizon outside the bridge the small section there looks lower so I assume its not water but land which would answer my original confusion.

You've done an excellent job well done, Sid

into you
by posthumous

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*
A candid capture that meets the challenge well.

You have captured a moment that most of us nosy people have been intrigued by at some point in our shared curiosity of people watching. The essence of your image is the mystery of the moment, as you say, are they arguing or loving? It is this very uncertainty that makes your image so appealing we can only see his face which gives nothing away except intensity of emotion. The ladies stance could be either defensive or flirting, it looks as though she may be smiling but we can't be sure and so the mystery, fortunately, remains.

Although you have done some correction to straighten it out it still feels in need of further straightening it leans a little to the right. The scene as a whole is quite distracting but the main moment is so intense and captivating it overpowers any other distractions. Having said that, I think the notice above the doorway would benefit from some dodging to subdue it.

Well observed and captured, Sid

Downtown street before daily traffic
by clickodak

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

A literal translation of the challenge theme that meets the challenge

It makes a change to be looking down on the street instead of from the normal street level looking up at the tall buildings so it makes for an interesting perspective. Your composition is good with the two blocks framing the street which is closed by the building at the top of the frame.

I'm sorry to say that the one thing that really lets it down is camera shake, there is softness throughout what ought to have been a very crisp and sharp image. I also think you missed a great opportunity to transform it into a much more dynamic image with your camera well supported and a slower shutter speed, probably about 1/2s. You could have made a feature of the motion of the traffic and people and emphasised how the city is always on the move against the permanently static buildings.

With a little more thought and attention to detail you would have improved the end result significantly, all part of the learning process, good luck with your future submissions, Sid

The Competition
by romil

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

Congratulations on your well deserved ribbon for an excellent image that meets the challenge very well.

What a pleasure it is to be given this wonderful image, I'm sure as soon as you saw this on your monitor you thought, YES! I'm gonna love this image anyway because I love mono and I love the inclusion of people to add interest so this ticks all my boxes straight away. The execution is perfect, the exposure and the timing are both spot on.

You have a lot of enthusiastic comments and a detailed one from 'SwordandScales', whom I largely agree with he has said all the things that I feel about the image myself. Obviously, as he has not elaborated on the technical aspects, I don't know but I imagine he may be talking about having a deeper DOF to perhaps see those behind a little more clearly, particularly the man with his clenched fist to his mouth. I can see there is an argument for that but I think I prefer it just the way it is, the emphasis is well and truly on the player deep in thought about his next move. Perhaps it may be the tiny hotspots of overexposure on the faces of some of them, particularly the clenched fist character, and the background but it is so minor and preferable to what would have been a tendency towards underexposure.

I love your composition with the board and protagonists in the region of the lower right hotspot giving the rest of the frame to the onlookers who are all equally immersed in the play. You feel that this is the highlight of their day, it feels the very reason for their existence such is the intensity of it all, brilliant.

A superb study that you have every right to be proud of, well done, Sid

address unknown
by posthumous

Comment:
*Hello from Sid and the Critique Club*

An appealing image that meets the challenge well.

The lovely soft focus and pastel shades work really well together here to produce an image that has an air of mystery about it. Your composition adds impact to the end result together with the subtle shift in tones from the dark base to the lighter top makes a great end result.

There's nothing I would alter here it is a lovely end result that has been well appreciated by your commenters with whom I concur, Sid.