Toro
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Composition: 5, there's nothing really wrong here, but shooting straight on from eye level doesn't make it that interesting
Technical: 7, nothing really off here. it's just too bad the colors don't really stand out more
Appeal: 5, this doesn't really move me one way or another
Challenge: 5, i'll have to take your word for it that this is broken. your image conveys more of a sense of old than broken (actually, from the look of the bin, it looks like it is still in use...)
Overall Calculated Average Score: 6

Abandoned
by rmtm333

Comment:
Composition: 5, fairly dead on
Technical: 6, while nothing in the shot is out of place, it also doesn't look like it challenged you too much from a technical standpoint
Appeal: 6, i have mixed feelings about the colors. i don't think the desat is particularly effective here. it's not really grabbing me.
Challenge: 8, while the image has broken windows in it, the way you have treated tends to highlight the stonework as the primary subject. as is, the broken glass is competing (and in my opinion, losing) to the wall.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 6, the one thing that makes this above average for me is the textures that you've captured. good luck!

Broken...I hate when that happens!
by Sweetlips

Comment:
Composition: 8, nicely organized
Technical: 8, dof drops off a bit
Appeal: 8, a little on the dark side, but acceptable
Challenge: 10, dead-on. beats the heck out of light bulbs!
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9, above average, for sure. solid piece of work. good luck!

Piggy
by kyebosh

Comment:
Composition: 7 - a little to tightly cropped, Technical: 4 - i could overlook the soft focus, but you really did a sloppy job on the editing, Appeal: 8 - it gave me a grin, Challenge: 10, Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

all in all, a good entry, above average. i just hope you didn't break the bank just for the sake of the challenge ;-)

splat!
by sidpixel

Comment:
i think the main thing that bothers me about this image is the transition of color between the color created by the lighting and the natural color of the yellow part of the yolk, as well as the lack of warmth in the lighting to the left. all in all, this is an above average effort. good luck!

Composition: 7, Technical: 8, Appeal: 7, Challenge: 10, Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

It Took Forever!
by tyt2000

Comment:
very, very creative. love the composition, lighting, and negative space. good work!

Composition: 10, Technical: 8, Appeal: 10, Challenge: 10, Overall Calculated Average Score: 10

Speak No Evil, See No Evil, Hear No Evil
by mariomel

Comment:
that ROCKS!!!

Windy Day Fun
by Firsty

Comment:
i can't wait to see who submitted this. it smacks of inede or coley. fantastic entry!

Sculpted by the Prevailing Winds
by sailracer_98

Comment:
i don't know why, but this tree looks familiar. as is, i don't see any evidence of wind...just a leaning tree. maybe if shot with a slower shutter, you would have caught some movement in the grass or clouds...

one more dance for the bird
by aznym

Comment:
there's only one person on this site capable of a shot such as this...well, there are a few daring enough to try, but only one who can actually deliver, as well as have the guts to put it out there! great image!