Seed
by MudHut

Comment:
Greetings from the Critque Club
I must first congratulate you on your first ribbon and well deserved.

So many aspects of this photo jump out at me as I look at this image, the lighting is that beautiful gold that many so try so hard to get, and the shallow depth of field makes it that much warmer for the eye to get lost looking at all the details and is a sharp contrast from most ribbon winners here that have very vibrant colors. I know that many people enjoyed the composition you chose and I think it is because it plays with the rule of thirds very well. Where those thirds intersect in the top left and bottom right are filled with soft out of focus areas while the top right and and bottom left have lines for the eye to catch so that you feel that you are swimming in the photo as so many people touched upon. The border works and all your tones are balanced across the whole image. Really a great entry and ribbon winner and congratulations! I am having a hard time finding anything to critique so I will just say Congratulations again and if you have any questions feel free to PM me.

rhythm and motion
by Rikki

Comment:
congrats on another ribbon, way to strike one for the Bay Area DPCer's!

Penn Relays, world's largest annual track meet, attended by 20,000 athletes and 100,000 plus fans.
by _eug

Comment:
Great job on this photo, congratulations and way to get a ribbon for all us D50 owners!!!

Turn the other cheek.
by moniepenny

Comment:
Critique Club
I think the idea you had for this image was great and one that took some courage to put into a contest like this and considering the content of using a woman who is apparently battered and not leaving I think it is done very well and can see the thoguht and planning that into it.

Composition and lighting
I think both of these aspects are really well done the lightning and definetly sets the mood that you were looking for, scared but a single light showing how lonely the character might be. I think a slightly softer light may have helped the image. If you have no camera/photo lighting equipment like me some cheap and easy alternative is to get a large piece of white paper and place in front of the light source or getting a piece of foamcore and turning the light source around and bouncing the light off of that. Just some cheap and easy suggestions. The placement of the character is very well done as the right eye is placed well in the frame according to the rule of thirds. Maybe pointing you fingers on your face towards your would have drawn even more attention to it also.
Focus and Color
It appears to me that your hair is more in focus then your face in this picture which takes away from the impact of the photo, but I understand how difficult it can be to focus on yourself when working alone. Another tip/trick I use is to put something where my face would be and focus on that, then use either the focus lock on your camera or turn off the auto focus whatever function keeps the focus on your camera the same while you are moving around.
As for the makeup it does seem to get lost in the photo. I think really putting alot of dark make up right in the eye socket is what happens when I have gotten black eyes, and you may need to even overdo so it looks over the top in person but would show up well on camera.
I also think this shot would have been a great candidate for a black and white entry as this would have made the viewer have less color to distract them and force them to look at the model. Something like this. I just used the the channel mixer in photoshop and clicked the monochrome button in the bottom right corner.

I think overall this image is very well done and with a few minor adjustments this would have easily been a 6+ photo. I hope I didn't detract you at all. All thes ideas are merely suggestions and if you have any questions or comments for me please send me a PM and I'd be glad to discuss them with you.

Geometry
by manic35

Comment:
A Critique Club Visit(sort of)
I believe this may be an unofficial visit since your pic was in my cue and I was trying to gather thoughts on it when the change over came and the photo disappeared but I wanted to critique it anyway.

At first look it does have that "pop" that so many voters love on this myself included. You managed to create a negative image that was very easy to look and kept many details that appeared to not be so negative such as the the silver? plate and the blues come across very natural smooth. The composition is very good as well as how even the light is across the two stars.

A few nit picky things about the photo is that there seems to be some dust on the middle star which was probably reflections and bright reflections but comes across as sensor dust. I think your border works to a certain degree but it appears the thin blue line is thinner on the top and on the rightthen it is on the bottom and left. I also think that the outer black is too thick and even though it was only mentioned once by a commenter I think many voters see a border around this size and may take a point away here and there.
I wonder if you tried positioning the star differently with the point a point pointed directly at the viewer if that would and either wider angle with the front exagerated and close to the viewrw if that would have raised the score abit.
Really this was an excellent entry and it is hard to find too many improvements on what you shot and I think you did an excellent job for the challenge.
Hope this helps and if you have any more questions you can send me a PM.

One Night Stand
by Chinabun

Comment:
I thought this shot should have placed much higher and was one of my highest rated photos in this challenge. This photo is well thought out and fits the challenge description to the tee, whereas many other photos seemed to be taken first and then looked for a title that fit the photo. IMO you were robbed!!! Well done.

dangerous work
by phoenix46

Comment:
CC Critque

First Impression
The first thing I noticed about this photo was the excellent use of rule of thirds and a strong composition with the lines slanted and triangles in the top and bottom of the photo. The title is good and I can see the dangerous aspect of the photo with the harness and safety lines on the worker.
Things to help your score
I think this photo has very little impact on a viewer that is looking at 200 plus photos. Especially in a challenge like Negative image where the viewer is looking to see something they would normally not see in an image. I think most viewers looked at it and so no major flaws with meeting the challenge or PP but did not see anything thing to make them vote higher or impact them to leave more comments. I am not sure how this would have looked in a color negative but I think it may have done better with abit more color in the image. Although I can see that there must be some danger with saftey lines attached to the worker, to show the dangerous element more in the photo it would have been nice by showing how high up the person is off the ground or what they are working on.
Post Processing
The image looks well balanced through out the tonal range, and even though the top right was possibly blown out in the original it seems to work when converted to negative. It is difficult to say what could have been done better in your PP without any comments on how you got where you are. A suggestion for when asking for a critique is to put as much detail into your comments about your image as possible.
Conclusion
I think the score on this image was really affected by the subject matter and that it was hard for the viewer to get a good feel for what is going on, but i think your composition is excellent and well executed. I think in this case it is a photo that has no real problems or issues that needed to be fixed but did not have something to grab the voter and have them bump up the score to a higher vote.
I hope this is helpful to you and if you have any questions about my comments feel free to send me a PM.

Serene
by GIS_boy

Comment:
A Critique from the CC
My first impression of this photo when I saw it in voting was that it had a huge wow factor and everything needed for a ribbon winner and congratulations on your top ten finish. I had this photo rated higher than every photo that finished above you. To me this has everything put together nearly perfectly. The tremendous Dof field and calm water truly give a serene feel and I also like it because it does not feel like you were forcing the viewer to look at orange and and blue like so many other entries. But I feel this can be a bit of a double edged sword on this site because so many voters want to see exactly what the challenge details are that they may knock a point down for the brown boardwalk for example. As I read through your comments received during the challenge it always strikes me that this is a contest and not an art exhibit, meaning that people want to see certain things in every photo, the rule of thirds and such.(In your specific case some voters commented that they would have liked to have seen the horizon moved up or down abit.) Eventhough I believe those can be broken, many people maybe eager to give critiques or generally feel that without seeing these rules it is an issue to be marked down on, they will take off a point here and there. So as far as composition goes I think it is amazing and I feel like thats how I would look at the scene if I was there. My only other question is why did you not use the full 150 kb size limit for your photo? I looked on your page at your other entries and they all seemed closer to the max allowance. Lastly as far as your title goes I noticed a few didn't think it was interesting enough even though I thought it fit well. The only alternative I could come up with would be "Complements of Sandgate Bay" or wherever the name of this specific pier is. I hope this was helpful and if you have anymore questions or think some of my comments are completely wrong and want to let me know about feel free to PM me. Personally I thought this would ribbon and finding things about I didn't like was very difficult for me.

Desperate Phone Call
by talikf

Comment:
This would totally work as a movie poster. I think as has been said before the lighting is great and emotion in the model's face is excellent and doesn't even appear to be acting in the shot. If I had to add any critique to the image it would be that by the wrist it is abit too sharp and has a bit of a halo and on the cheek above the right eye the skin appears to have a alittle bright spots that attract the eye. In most cases it wouldn't matter but movie posters always seem to have the skins tones way over processed. If I was voting I would have voted it an 8 or 9 then sulked on to the next entry thinking about how much better this then my photo for the challenge.

2.75 Bubbles
by aimeethetoo

Comment:
------------****Greetings from the critique club****------------
I think this was a really creative idea for the negative image challenge and you executed your idea very well. As with many images in this challenge with very strong colors after inversion they could be hard to look at and your image is very easy on the eyes and the bubbles make me want to see closer into the them to see the details.

As far as composition goes I think it is really well done. I may have cropped slightly differently by having the bubbles abit higher up and the wand slightly to the right to make use of the rule of thirds. This woud have placed the wand in one of the places the eye is most drawn to and from there it would follow the bubbles. Also I can faintly see some blueish tint in the background underneath the bubbles which can be a small distraction. (Although I didn't notice them at first.)

I think the post processing would have helped your score abit, although I know it is difficult when working with a negative image. I noticed that you used invert to make you image negative. I would suggest using curves instead as it allows you to have more tonal control over the image, you simply change the curves low point to the high point and vice versa or from this / to this \. I hope that makes sense. Your bubbles seems abit overblown and it is hard to distinguish where the bubble ends and the background begins in some parts. Although I am not sure if this was intentional or not I could see voters taking a point away for that. The other thing that really strikes mee is that you are very blue and there is no change in the blue from your hair, shirt and skin tone and I am not sure how that is and perhaps voters who didn't comment may have thought this also and took a point down also. So maybe where shirt that was different than your skin or even some with lots of different colors to see how that would have looked.

Overall I think this image was really well done and as I critiqued it I liked it more. The border I think worked for your image too. The inside of the bubbles are great and it was a creative and well thought out idea. I hope this is helpful to you. If you have any more questions feel free to send me a PM.