Inside a dream
by XShadow

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Creative idea and point of view. Composition is good but a little tight in the frame. Focus on the eye is good. DOF feels a little to shallow ... or a little too deep, I'm not sure which. Color doesn't help the image for me.

Tension
by Cjddrum1

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Photo conveys a certain dramatic tension which I like.

Rise
by Tuckersmom

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Otherwise this is a beautiful photo. Lightig, contrast, color, DOF are all superb. I probably would have given it 4 more points if it compared well with whomever you are emulating.

promenade à l'Esplanade
by anotherday

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Otherwise this is a terrific candid photo. It conveys very well the attitude that I have come to associate as French chic ... stylish, arrogant, self absorbed ... and I don't mean this in a bad way but more as a behavioral style. I like the high point of view. I like the angle. Focus could be a little better. I have lost some detail on the subjects but can read the Belgacom ADSL boxes. Since this is advanced editing, I might have brightened the people a bit ... not so much that you lose them in the background but enough to give me a little more detail in their clothing. These may not have been your intention but they would be my preferences.

Watch
by Steveo77z

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Composition feels a bit cramped on the bottom and the left. In contrast to the white background, richer tones in the strap would have improved my reaction to your photo.

Wisp
by karimelsahy

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Nice image which I would have given a couple of more point to if I knew who you were emulating.

Disrepair
by dahved

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Your photo is well and appropriately titled. It conveys the emotion of disrepair at several levels.

No More Cupcakes
by blazingmoonlight

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. This is a well enough executed photo but the genre doesn't appeal to me.

Winchester by Night
by kano

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. I would really like to see this bigger. If the image will stand it without deteriorating into pixels, I would have preferred this at 640 X 488.

My Lovely
by Konador

Comment:
Part of the fun of the challenge is comparing the photos to the work of the photographers they're paying tribute to. I can't figure out who that would be in this case. Lovely girl. Nice focus on the eyes. Good range of color and light levels.