Pottery
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I rated this a 6 because I think the exposure is solid and the fade into black at the bottom is well done. Brighter light at the top and a slightly more interesting composition would have gotten a point or two extra from me.

Triple your pleasure
by DCThiessen

Comment:
What I like about this image most is the clarity of the colors, and hopefully, you'll have in your notes what you used. I rated this an 8 because I think the stems could are just a little off in color.

Fore!
by n1tr0g1rl

Comment:
Lighting could be improved a bit by being brighter and more directed at the "face". The background is far enough away to be perfect, and this is cropped perfectly.

Young Prayer
by shadowangel

Comment:
Great idea to use the candles as fill light, as it really met the challenge and the cancle light added to the mood. The folds on the background distract a bit though, and could have been reduced by moving the curtain back from the subject.

Tired Cowboy & His Shadow
by rmlutgen

Comment:
This is almost perfectly lit. I like the fact that there is reduced detail in the dark hat, yet there is some detail in the shirt. I also like the reflections in the glass, as I think they really add some depth to the picture. The detail on the paneling probably looks great on your wall, but just isn't helping this otherwise great shot as it distracts from the subject.

Phantom Dance
by Xarthan

Comment:
This is an above average photo with great colors, and interesting subjects. If the three major subjects were sharper and clearer, I think it would be a really strong entry.

Splendor In The Grass
by Rooster

Comment:
I gave this a 6 (almost a seven.) I thought it was well exposed, and the colors are great, including the background. I would have given another point or two for more DOF on the near grass and on the velor.

Frankly, I think you should have scored well higher than you did, certainly higher than me.

A luminous blanket
by Ylgur

Comment:
A little sharper focus would help this, but it is a good idea for the challenge..

Shadows of Light
by xdavemanx

Comment:
Technically sound, great lighting, just a little grainy.

David & Goliath (ll)
by jjbeguin

Comment:
This is well composed for the challenge, but I thought the exposure on the wall was just a little too dark.