Memories
by whiteroom

Comment:
I love the overall tonality of this. The kids playing is perfect for the category you chose. . The leading line sends your eye through the shot. Nicely done.

Friendship Complements
by banmorn

Comment:
I see lots of flowers against a black background, but these two gerbera daisies really stand out to me. I think the orange frame helps this along with the same color orange. This is tack sharp and the composition is spot on. I love the single stem pushing up and out to give the eye an line to follow in the shot. Great lighting too. This could also work for anniversary as it is two blooms! One of my favorites.

Thinking of you
by gaurawa

Comment:
This is lovely. The whole scene has a velvety feel to it and yet it's tack sharp. The green tones with a touch of blue here and there is just wonderful. I like that you are down on the level of the rocks, so that the water is coming right "over you." The composition is done so well and the natural frame of the trees is perfect. Really nicely done.

Happy Baaaa Mitzvah!
by Riponlady

Comment:
This image is a hoot. I think the category title is a bit specific, as I thought we were supposed to use a general category, but no biggie. The shot is wonderful. I love the detail of his woolly coat. The light helps highlight that and the "in your face" sense is hilarious. I think "Hi" or "What's New?" Might've worked better, but that's just me. In a perfect set up, the other sheep wouldn't have been behind him, but in the setting, I'm sure that's not possible. Really fun and imaginative.

Bon Voyage
by joansuzy

Comment:
Really perfect for the challenge. It gives that wanderlust sense of "let's go somewhere." I like the glistening water and the blue tones of the sky and the water. The end of the day sense helps create a peaceful mood. Nicely composed and naturally framed with the boughs of the trees. 8

Sympathy
by sprite777

Comment:
I liked this the minute it popped up on my screen. The monochromatic theme is very effective with the petals blending slowly into the light. Perfect for the category you chose. There is enough detail for it to work, but it has a softness that I like. The DOF is good.The light to the left and upper area might be a tad bright, but no demerits for that as it could just be my monitor. With a light colored flower, you have to have a lighter level somewhere anyway. This would be pretty even if it weren't for a challenge as specific as this.

Bereavement
by Tallbloke

Comment:
This is lovely and perfect for the category. The dark muted colors are beautiful but do certainly denote the sad sense of the card. The long shadows help add to that as well. The misty/soft filter works with an ethereal "another world" sense. Quite striking. I'd love the photograph anyway, whethere this were the challenge or not. That blown out light in the upper right is a tad distracting, but overall quite nicely done. 8

Miss You
by annah

Comment:
This is super imaginative and I like it VERY much. My main complaint would be all of the "props." The Green Day album, pen, portable phone, etc don't really add to the shot. I mean, they probably refer to the person specifically that you miss, but for the general buying public, I think no props at all, other than maybe something that denotes missing a person on a more generic level. Does that make sense? Since all of the words are kind of busy and your eye is reading them, maybe no belt on the jeans too. It might be kind of schmaltzy, but maybe holding an empty Valentine candy box, or a picture frame turned away from the viewer, so you just see the back of it. Just me rambling and thinking out loud here. The shadows and ligh tare excellent. The placement of the figure's torso to the far left works well too, Without all of the props, there would be more negative space, which would give it more of a lonely feeling in my opnion. Have her laying on grass instead of the rug too like she's outside day dreaming of the person she is missing. Hope all of this is helpful. You certainly have a great eye for detail and the composition is good - just maybe a few less things would work for me. GOOD LUCK 7

Anniversary
by smilebig4me1x

Comment:
I liked this the minute I saw it. It could also serve in the "Thinking of You," "Get Well," and even the "Sympathy" catetgory. My only complaint is the 2nd flower to the right. I think the pink of it's center is a tad distracting. I think if it were me, I'd clone it out so you are only looking at a single blossom. BUT having said that, to truly denote the duality of two people married, I would have liked to see two complete blossoms overlapping as the "two become one" type idea for marriage. The lighting is exquisite and the frame really works well with the color pallette of the shot. Well done. 8

S I L E N C E
by pzig98

Comment:
This is a great studio set up. Love the soft nostalgic filter. Nice desaturation of color. The subdued lighting and subject matter are thought provoking. VERY NICE. Looks like a poster. I like the wide border too.