Trees
by kawesttex

Comment:
I really like the lighting in this one. I love that look of sun against gray / dark sky. It looks to me like it could be rotated just a hint to the right to balance it out a little bit. Also, those tree branches are small and with that many together they seem to me to give a "soft" look, sort of out of focus, but hard to tell if they truly are.

I really like the composition and subject. The snow just highlights everything so nicely. I can see why it's a scene you'd like to capture. Just because I'm a photo editing nut, I'd probably give this a soft glow sort of treatment. Just a bit. But I do like it as it is also.

MCRD San Diego
by kawesttex

Comment:
This would have been a wonderful entry for the "light" challenge. I would have given it an 8. Very nice lighting (perfect time of day) and good eye for the composition. Neat shot.

OKC Memorial Chairs
by kawesttex

Comment:
This is an awesome shot. We were there a few years ago, but during the day. I didn't realize they lit up like this. I think I would have liked a closer veiw of several chairs together...like maybe 4 or 5 in a line.

Home sweet home
by Jinjit

Comment:
What nice work on this one. I think maybe it would have placed higher if the main subject was pink instead of the background. Still, as a photo on it's own, it's really one of the strongest and most interesting in the challenge IMO. Great focus and lighting, and I like the bits of blue in the background that set the other colors off so well. Congratulations on a great shot.

Natural Redheads
by BAMartin

Comment:
Awww...I just want to reach out and pet these guys. Don't know how you got such a close shot, but the two of them together is wonderful. It almost makes the viewer want to place some sort of caption with the expessions. I really like how the faces fill the frame and are really the focus. Nice DOF.

Wow..just read a few of the other comments. I'm not an animal photographer, but I really like the lighting and composition of this. The eyes didn't bother me at all. I guess I just get an overall "feeling" from the shot of closeness between these two and the viewer, and for me the eyes are only a small part of that here.

Grand Canyon
by BAMartin

Comment:
What an amazing place for photography. I wish I lived close to all the canyon areas out there. This is such a nicely composed shot and it looks like you had a nice day for it. I was out there for the first time a few years ago, but I'm sure I'll be back. Photos like this one make me want to go NOW! :)

Poisonous Hue
by thatcloudthere

Comment:
Even if I call the shade pink, which in my opinion it is not, it still is not the primary focus of the shot. There just isn't enough of an interesting subject here to hold my attention.

That's all she left behind...
by Moose101

Comment:
Fun shot. It's lacking some wow factor for me...not sure what. I suppose outside of the "pink" theme, it wouldn't hold too much interest for me as is. Definitely fits the challenge, though.

pink power
by gtp1164

Comment:
I like the idea and these are gorgeous roses. I think the composition suffersf from having the empty area in the bottom right and the other two roses cut off. It appears to me to be a somewhat unbalanced look. Also, the water drops are nice but the overall lighting is very dark and it doesn't bring out the color. I'll bet they smelled good!

My Favorite Color
by bruski

Comment:
Lots of pink and a very cute girl, but the photo suffers from the lighting in my opinion. Too dark, especially on the face, and also slightly out of focus.